Golan v. Holder
Citations
- 132 S. Ct. 873
- 181 L. Ed. 2d 835
- 565 U.S. 302
- 2012 U.S. LEXIS 907
About this case
Golan v. Holder
Golan v. Holder,[a] 565 U.S. 302 (2012), was a US Supreme Court case that dealt with copyright and the public domain . It held that the "limited time" language of the United States Constitution 's Copyright Clause does not preclude the extension of copyright protections to works previously in the public domain.[1]
In particular, the case challenged the constitutionality of the application of Section 514 of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act of 1994, which implemented the provisions of trade agreements seeking to equalize copyright protection on an international basis. In the United States, the Act restored copyright for foreign works that had previously entered the public domain in the United States.
The two main arguments against the application of the Act in the case were that restoring copyright violates the "limited time" language of the United States Constitution's Copyright Clause, and that restoring to copyright works that had passed into the public domain interferes with the people's First Amendment right to use, copy and otherwise exploit the works and to freely express themselves through these works, thus also violating the Constitution's Copyright Clause.[2]
The US Supreme Court held on January 18, 2012 that Section 514 of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act does not exceed Congress's authority under the Copyright Clause, and the court affirmed the judgment of the lower court by 6–2, with the opinion written by Justice Ginsburg .[3] [2] [4] The practical effect of the decision is to confirm that works that were previously free to use, such as Prokofiev 's _Peter and the Wolf _, are no longer in the public domain and are subject to use only with the permission of the copyright holder, such as through paid licensing, until their copyright term expires again.[5]
Contents
History
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Golan_v._Holder&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: History")
After the Supreme Court of the United States upheld the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act in _Eldred v. Ashcroft _ (2003), the United States District Court for the District of Colorado dismissed the plaintiffs' challenge to that act in 2004 (Golan v. Ashcroft).[6] The remaining constitutional challenge to the 1994 Uruguay Round Agreements Act was dismissed the following year (Golan v. Gonzales).[7]
The case affected the copyright status of potentially millions of works,[8]
including:[_citation needed
_]
_Metropolis _ (1927)
_The Third Man _ (1949)
The works of Igor Stravinsky
Several works of H. G. Wells , including the film _Things to Come _ (1936)
The case was heard by District Chief Judge Lewis Babcock and was decided by the United States District Court for the District of Colorado in 2005. It was appealed at the Tenth Circuit .
On September 4, 2007, Judge Robert H. Henry of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed the district court's dismissal of the CTEA claim, as foreclosed by Eldred , and the district court's holding that § 514 of the URAA does not exceed the limitations inherent in the Copyright Clause.[9]
However, the Appeals Court did find "Based on the Eldred Court's analysis, we examine the bedrock principle of copyright law that works in the public domain remain there and conclude that § 514 alters the traditional contours of copyright protection by deviating from this principle"[10] and concluded "since § 514 has altered the traditional contours of copyright protection in a manner that implicates plaintiffs' right to free expression, it must be subject to First Amendment review."[11] It remanded the case to the district court.
U.S. Supreme Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Golan_v._Holder&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: U.S. Supreme Court")
A related issue was then brought before the court as Golan v. Holder after conductors Lawrence Golan and Richard Kapp filed suit. In a holding published on April 3, 2009, Judge Babcock reversed his earlier finding that the First Amendment was not applicable to resurrecting foreign copyright claims. Judge Babcock found that aspects of the 1994 Uruguay Round Agreements Act , which brought some works whose copyright had lapsed back under copyright, violated First Amendment rights of so-called reliance parties,[12] i.e., parties who had been using a work formerly in the public domain before the URAA became effective, relying on the work being in the public domain, and who would now no longer be able to do so.[13] He wrote,
In the United States, that body of law includes the bedrock principle that works in the public domain remain in the public domain. Removing works from the public domain violated Plaintiffs' vested First Amendment interests. [...] Accordingly—to the extent Section 514 suppresses the right of reliance parties to use works they exploited while the works were in the public domain—Section 514 is substantially broader than necessary to achieve the Government's interest.[14]
He also indicated a possible solution by suggesting that the protection of reliance parties be made not limited in time. However, further appeals by copyright owners were expected.[15]
On June 21, 2010, the Tenth Circuit reversed the judgment of the district court and remanded with instructions to grant summary judgment in favor of the government, thus upholding the constitutionality of the URAA copyright restoration.[16] [17] Golan filed for certiorari in the Supreme Court of the United States asking for the Court to hear the case.[18] On March 7, 2011, the Court granted the writ of certiorari.[19] [20] Oral argument was held October 5, 2011.[21]
On June 12, 2011, the International Music Score Library Project (IMSLP, Petrucci Music Library) announced they would submit an amicus curiae brief in the case; a group of Harvard Law School students, supervised by Professor [Charles Nesson](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Nesson "
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
Oral argument
- ListenArgued59 min recording
Source: CourtListener oral-argument corpus (CC0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- referring to “Berne’s 164 member states”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Ginsburg, Breyer, Kagan, Alito
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
41 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Disney Enterprises, Inc. v. Vidangel, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2017-08-24· cited 250×
- Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Symantec Corp.Federal Circuit· 2016-09-30· cited 193×
- Comptroller of Treasury of Md. v. WynneSupreme Court· 2015-05-18· cited 162×
- Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Supreme Court· 2013-03-19· cited 145×
- Doe v. City of AlbuquerqueTenth Circuit· 2012-01-20· cited 140×
- TD Bank NA v. Vernon Hill, IIThird Circuit· 2019-07-01· cited 132×
- WPIX, Inc. v. Ivi, Inc.Second Circuit· 2012-08-27· cited 122×
- Williams v. GayeNinth Circuit· 2018-03-21· cited 74×
- Ramos Perea v. Editorial Cultural, Inc.First Circuit· 2021-09-13· cited 60×
- Broadcast Music, Inc. v. Prana Hospitality, Inc.S.D. New York· 2016-01-21· cited 57×
- Oracle America, Inc. v. Google Inc.Federal Circuit· 2014-05-09· cited 56×
- Impression Products, Inc. v. Lexmark Int'l, Inc.Supreme Court· 2017-05-30· cited 44×
- Greene v. General Hospital Corp.First Circuit· 2015-07-16· cited 40×
- Design Basics, LLC v. Signature Construction, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2021-04-23· cited 40×
- Guedes v. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, & ExplosivesD.C. Circuit· 2019-02-25· cited 32×
- Bikram's Yoga College of India, L.P. v. Evolation Yoga, LLCNinth Circuit· 2015-10-08· cited 27×
- SIGNATURE LEASING LLC v. BUYER'S GROUP LLCSupreme Court of Oklahoma· 2020-06-09· cited 27×
- Cambridge University Press v. PattonEleventh Circuit· 2014-10-17· cited 25×
- Fahmy v. Jay-ZNinth Circuit· 2018-05-31· cited 25×
- Beastie Boys v. Monster Energy Co.S.D. New York· 2015-02-20· cited 19×
Cites
25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Ward v. Rock Against RacismSupreme Court· 1989-08-30· cited 3,406×
- Graham v. John Deere Co. of Kansas CitySupreme Court· 1966-02-21· cited 3,371×
- Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Federal Communications CommissionSupreme Court· 1994-08-24· cited 1,695×
- United States v. Detroit Timber & Lumber Co.Supreme Court· 1906-02-19· cited 1,300×
- Cox Broadcasting Corp. v. CohnSupreme Court· 1975-03-03· cited 1,289×
- Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc. v. Nation EnterprisesSupreme Court· 1985-05-20· cited 1,191×
- Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc.Supreme Court· 1984-01-17· cited 978×
- Kewanee Oil Co. v. Bicron Corp.Supreme Court· 1974-05-13· cited 566×
- Mazer v. SteinSupreme Court· 1954-04-12· cited 560×
- Sorrell v. IMS Health Inc.Supreme Court· 2011-06-23· cited 516×
- Dastar Corp. v. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp.Supreme Court· 2003-06-02· cited 486×
- TWENTIETH CENTURY MUSIC CORP. Et Al. v. AIKENSupreme Court· 1975-06-17· cited 233×
- Eldred v. AshcroftSupreme Court· 2003-01-15· cited 226×
- Wheaton and Donaldson v. Peters and GriggSupreme Court· 1834-03-19· cited 205×
- Fox Film Corp. v. DoyalSupreme Court· 1932-05-16· cited 180×
- McCLURG v. KINGSLANDSupreme Court· 1843-02-18· cited 138×
- Golan v. AshcroftD. Colorado· 2004-03-15· cited 26×
- Evans v. JordanSupreme Court· 1815-03-18· cited 22×
- Blanchard v. SpragueU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Massachusetts· 1839-05-15· cited 18×
- Golan v. HolderTenth Circuit· 2010-06-21· cited 17×
Other cases named Golan v. Holder
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.