Tenth Circuit· 3/2/2018
Fernandez v. Clean House, LLC
Citations
- 883 F.3d 1296
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that a plaintiff “need not anticipate” an affirmative defense in its pleading
- stating that a court may grant a motion to dismiss based on a statute of limitations defense only “when the complaint itself admits all the elements of the affirmative defense by alleging the factual basis for those elements”
- “A plaintiff need not anticipate in the complaint an affirmative defense that may be raised by the defendant; it is the defendant’s burden to plead an affirmative defense.”
- “Only when the plaintiff pleads itself out of court—that is, admits all the ingredients of an impenetrable defense—may a complaint that otherwise states a claim be dismissed under Rule 12(b)(6
- “To be sure, on occasion it is proper to dismiss a claim on the pleadings based on an affirmative defense. But that is only when the complaint itself admits all the elements of the affirmative defense by alleging the factual basis for those elements.”
- “To be sure, on occasion it is proper to dismiss a claim on the pleadings based on an affirmative defense. But that is only when the complaint itself admits all the elements of the affirmative defense by alleging the factual basis for those elements.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Briscoe, Hartz, Phillips
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
13 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Whiteside v. Hover-Davis-Inc.Second Circuit· 2021-04-27· cited 151×
- Ullery v. BradleyTenth Circuit· 2020-02-10· cited 110×
- Herrera v. City of EspanolaTenth Circuit· 2022-04-27· cited 95×
- Rivero v. Univ. N.M. Board of RegentsTenth Circuit· 2020-02-24· cited 75×
- Malik Weatherly v. Ford Motor CompanyEighth Circuit· 2021-04-19· cited 61×
- Bistline v. ParkerTenth Circuit· 2019-03-14· cited 57×
- Frost v. ADTTenth Circuit· 2020-01-17· cited 16×
- Wyo-Ben Inc. v. HaalandTenth Circuit· 2023-03-20· cited 13×
- Hubbard v. J Message Grp. Corp.D. New Mexico· 2018-07-11· cited 4×
- James McCarthy v. Medicus Healthcare Solutions, LLCD. New Hampshire· 2022-04-04· cited 1×
- Metzinger v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2024-10-25
- Messerli v. AW DistributingTenth Circuit· 2025-09-03
- Vasquez-Garcia v. CenturionTenth Circuit· 2026-04-15
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Ashcroft v. IqbalSupreme Court· 2009-05-18· cited 149,772×
- Bell Atlantic Corp. v. TwomblySupreme Court· 2007-05-21· cited 146,720×
- Gomez v. ToledoSupreme Court· 1980-05-27· cited 2,697×
- McLaughlin v. Richland Shoe Co.Supreme Court· 1988-05-16· cited 1,362×
- Xechem, Inc., and Xechem International, Inc. v. Bristol-Myers Squibb CompanySeventh Circuit· 2004-06-23· cited 226×
- Victor Rivera v. Peri & Sons Farms, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2013-11-13· cited 175×
- Duncan Miller v. Shell Oil Co.Tenth Circuit· 1965-05-20· cited 136×
- Slater v. AG Edwards & Sons, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2013-07-09· cited 119×
- Creative Consumer Concepts, Inc. v. KreislerTenth Circuit· 2009-04-21· cited 113×
- Elliott Levin v. William MillerSeventh Circuit· 2014-08-14· cited 39×
- Mumby v. PURE ENERGY SERVICES (USA), INC.Tenth Circuit· 2011-02-22· cited 35×
- Ghailani v. SessionsTenth Circuit· 2017-06-21· cited 35×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.