Ellis v. Davis
Citations
- 109 U.S. 485
- 3 S. Ct. 327
- 27 L. Ed. 1006
- 1883 U.S. LEXIS 991
Syllabus
<p>Conflict of Laws — Constitutional Law — Jurisdiction—Louisiana—Practice— Probate of Wills — Wills.</p> <p>1. When an heir at law brings a suit in equity to set aside the probate of a will in Louisiana as null and void, and to recover real estate and prays for an accounting of rents and profits by an adverse party in possession, who claims under the will, this' court will refuse to entertain the prayer for recovery of possession, if ^he complainant has a plain, adequate, and complete remedy at the common law. Hipp v. Babin, 19 Howard, 271, affirmed.</p> <p>2. Circuit courts, as courts of equity, have no general jurisdiction for annulling or affirming the probate of a will. Broderick’s Will, 21 Wall. 503, affirmed.</p> <p>3. Jurisdiction as to wills, and their probate as such, is neither included in nor excepted out of the grant of judicial power to the courts of the United States. . So far as it is esparte and merely administrative, it is not conferred, and it cannot be exercised by them at all, until, in a ease at law or in equity, its exercise becomes necessary to settle a controversy of which a court of the United States may take cognizance by reason of the citizenship of the parties.</p> <p>4. If by the law obtaining in a State, a suit whose object is to annul and set aside the probate of a will of real estate can be maintained, it may be maintained in a federal court, when the parties are on one side citizens of the State in which the will is proved, and on .the other citizens of other States. Gaines v. Fuentes, 92 U. S. 18, approved.</p> <p>5. By the laws of Louisiana an action of revendication is the proper one to be brought for the purpose of asserting the legal title and right of posses- . sion of the heir at law to the succession, when another is in possession under claim of title by virtue of a will admitted to probate. In a proper case as to parties this action can be brought in the Circuit Court of the United States. And as it furnishes a plain,' adeq
Judges: Matthews
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
94 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- County of Allegheny v. Frank Mashuda Co.Supreme Court· 1959-10-12· cited 896×
- Marshall v. MarshallSupreme Court· 2006-05-01· cited 695×
- Byers v. McAuleySupreme Court· 1893-05-10· cited 281×
- Farrell v. O'BrienSupreme Court· 1905-05-29· cited 249×
- Moran v. SturgesSupreme Court· 1894-05-26· cited 177×
- Marvine Markham v. City of Newport News, a Municipal CorporationFourth Circuit· 1961-06-19· cited 147×
- Sutton v. EnglishSupreme Court· 1918-03-04· cited 145×
- Simmons v. SaulSupreme Court· 1891-03-02· cited 140×
- Hess v. ReynoldsSupreme Court· 1885-01-05· cited 123×
- Lois Jones v. Thomas BrennanSeventh Circuit· 2006-08-14· cited 115×
- In Re JohnsonSupreme Court· 1897-05-10· cited 113×
- Upshur County v. RichSupreme Court· 1890-04-14· cited 94×
- Clark v. BeverSupreme Court· 1891-03-02· cited 85×
- Brun v. MannEighth Circuit· 1906-11-07· cited 77×
- United States v. WilsonSupreme Court· 1886-04-26· cited 66×
- Land Title & Trust Co. v. Asphalt Co.Third Circuit· 1903-12-18· cited 46×
- Dunham v. StitzbergNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1948-08-10· cited 40×
- Sawyer v. WhiteEighth Circuit· 1903-04-13· cited 36×
- State v. South Penn Oil Co.West Virginia Supreme Court· 1896-04-04· cited 34×
- Miami County Nat. Bank of Paola, Kan. v. BancroftTenth Circuit· 1941-07-17· cited 32×
Cites
11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Boom Co. v. PattersonSupreme Court· 1879-03-18· cited 568×
- Root v. Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1882-03-13· cited 285×
- Gaines v. FuentesSupreme Court· 1876-03-20· cited 191×
- Ex Parte BoydSupreme Court· 1882-05-18· cited 50×
- Abston v. AbstonSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1860-03-15· cited 13×
- Sophie v. DuplessisSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1847-06-15· cited 10×
- Succession of DupuySupreme Court of Louisiana· 1849-12-15· cited 9×
- Lewis' Heirs v. HisSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1833-04-15· cited 6×
- Succession of Hoover v. YorkSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1878-04-15· cited 5×
- Gibson v. DooleySupreme Court of Louisiana· 1880-10-15· cited 4×
- Sharp v. KnoxSupreme Court of Louisiana· 1830-09-15· cited 3×
Other cases named Ellis v. Davis
7 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Ellis v. DavisCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1890-04-26· cited 18×
- Ellis v. DavisFifth Circuit· 1925-02-06· cited 2×
- Ellis v. DavisDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2008-05-20
- Ellis v. DavisDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2008-08-19
- Ellis v. DavisLouisiana Court of Appeal· 1957-11-26
- Ellis v. DavisDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2008-08-19
- Ellis v. DavisU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Louisiana· 1879-11-15
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.