Elder v. Wood
Citations
- 208 U.S. 226
- 28 S. Ct. 263
- 52 L. Ed. 464
- 1908 U.S. LEXIS 1435
Syllabus
<p>Á valid subsisting mining location, such as the Comstock lode, or an interest therein, is property distinct from the land itself, vendible, inheritable and taxable as such, by the State, notwithstanding the land may be unpatented by the United States.</p> <p>When the collection of a tax on such an interest is enforced by sale, the tax deed conveys merely the right of possession and does not affect any interest of the United States, and the construction of the state statutes, and the conformity thereto of the tax levy and sale, are matters exclusively for the state court to' determine, and this court is without jurisdiction to review its decision.</p> <p>Sections 340, 341 of the laws of Colorado of 1881, taxing interests in unpatented mining claims and making the right of possession the subject of levy and sale, are not in conflict with § 4 of the Colorado enabling act of March 3, 1875, 18 Stat. 474, providing that no tax shall be imppsed on lands or property of the United States.</p> <p>Where the Federal question below was whether a tax sale deprived the owner of his property without due process of law because the notice, being published on Sunday, was insufficient, and the state court did not pass on that question but sustained tlie tax title under the state statutes making tax deeds prima facie evidence and of limitations, the non-Federal grounds are adequate to support the judgment and this court is without jurisdiction to review it on writ of error under § 709, Rev. Stat.</p>
Judges: Moody
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
29 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. County of AlleghenySupreme Court· 1944-05-08· cited 448×
- S. R. A., Inc. v. MinnesotaSupreme Court· 1946-03-25· cited 202×
- Fox Film Corp. v. DoyalSupreme Court· 1932-05-16· cited 180×
- Wilbur v. United States Ex Rel. KrushnicSupreme Court· 1930-01-06· cited 95×
- Irwin v. WrightSupreme Court· 1922-03-20· cited 84×
- Union Oil Co. of Cal. v. SmithSupreme Court· 1919-03-31· cited 76×
- In Re Initiative Petition No. 315, State Question No. 553Supreme Court of Oklahoma· 1982-05-20· cited 55×
- Ickes v. Virginia-Colorado Development Corp.Supreme Court· 1935-06-03· cited 43×
- Tosco Corp. v. HodelD. Colorado· 1985-05-01· cited 29×
- Chicago & North Western Transportation Co. v. PedersenWisconsin Supreme Court· 1977-11-14· cited 27×
- Oil Shale Corporation v. MortonD. Colorado· 1973-12-19· cited 23×
- Bradford v. MorrisonSupreme Court· 1909-02-23· cited 20×
- Lake Canal Reservoir Co. v. BeetheSupreme Court of Colorado· 2010-03-22· cited 20×
- United States v. RizzinelliD. Idaho· 1910-08-24· cited 18×
- Marathon Oil Co. v. LujanD. Colorado· 1990-06-20· cited 14×
- Dawson v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1949-02-07· cited 10×
- Dingess v. Huntington Development & Gas Co.Fourth Circuit· 1921-02-15· cited 9×
- United States v. HurstD. Wyoming· 1924-10-29· cited 8×
- United States v. Canyon CountyD. Idaho· 1916-04-29· cited 8×
- Rummel v. MusgraveSupreme Court of Colorado· 1960-03-28· cited 6×
Cites
6 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Belk v. MeagherSupreme Court· 1881-12-18· cited 306×
- Forbes v. GraceySupreme Court· 1877-05-18· cited 135×
- Redfield v. ParksSupreme Court· 1889-11-18· cited 78×
- Manuel v. WulffSupreme Court· 1894-03-26· cited 63×
- St. Louis Mining & Milling Co. v. Montana Mining Co.Supreme Court· 1898-10-31· cited 50×
- Leathe v. ThomasSupreme Court· 1907-11-11· cited 31×
Other cases named Elder v. Wood
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.