Dobie v. New Haven
Citations
- 204 Conn. App. 583
Syllabus
The plaintiff sought to recover damages for personal injuries that he sus- tained when his vehicle struck an open manhole while he was traveling on a roadway maintained by the defendant city. The plaintiff alleged that his injuries were the result of the city's negligence, as one of its snowplows had knocked off the manhole cover and its operator failed to stop and secure the roadway. The city filed a motion to dismiss the complaint, arguing that the facts alleged stated a claim of injury arising out of a highway defect for which the defective highway statute (§ 13a- 149) provided the exclusive remedy and that the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction because the plaintiff failed to give notice of his injuries as required by the statute. The court sustained the plaintiff's objection to the motion, noting that the complaint alleged that the plaintiff's injuries were caused by the negligence of the snowplow driver rather than by a defect in the road. The matter proceeded to trial and a jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff. The city filed a posttrial motion to dismiss, renewing its claim that the court lacked subject matter jurisdiction due to the plaintiff's failure to provide the requisite notice pursuant to § 13a-149. The court denied the motion, again stating that the plaintiff was asserting a negligence claim rather than a defective highway claim, and rendered judgment in favor the plaintiff, from which the city appealed to this court. Held that the trial court improperly denied the city's posttrial motion to dismiss the plaintiff's action for lack of subject matter jurisdiction because § 13a-149 provided the plaintiff's exclusive remedy against the city and the plaintiff failed to comply with its notice requirements: the plaintiff's injuries were caused by an open manhole, which constituted a highway defect within the meaning of § 13a-149 because it was an object in the traveled path that obstructed or hindered the use of the road for the purpose
Judges: Elgo; Cradle; Alexander
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
3 cases in this archive cite this case.
Cites
17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Ferreira v. PringleSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2001-02-13· cited 118×
- Conboy v. StateSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2009-07-21· cited 100×
- Stroiney v. Crescent Lake Tax DistrictSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1987-11-17· cited 92×
- Hewison v. City of New HavenSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1867-02-15· cited 82×
- Martin v. Town of PlainvilleSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1997-03-04· cited 76×
- D'Angelo v. McGoldrickSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1996-12-03· cited 38×
- Prato v. City of New HavenSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1998-09-01· cited 38×
- Bellman v. Town of West HartfordConnecticut Appellate Court· 2006-07-04· cited 27×
- Kozlowski v. Commissioner of TransportationSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2005-07-19· cited 25×
- McIntosh v. SullivanSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2005-07-05· cited 25×
- HIMMELSTEIN v. Town of WindsorSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2012-04-03· cited 24×
- Reinke v. SingSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2018-03-13· cited 23×
- Himmelstein v. Town of WindsorConnecticut Appellate Court· 2009-07-29· cited 20×
- Wenc v. City of New LondonSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1995-11-14· cited 20×
- MacHado v. City of HartfordSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2009-07-07· cited 17×
- Giannoni v. Commissioner of TransportationSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2016-08-09· cited 15×
- Bagg v. Town of ThompsonConnecticut Appellate Court· 2009-04-28· cited 8×
Other cases named Dobie v. New Haven
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.