Davis v. Wallace
Citations
- 257 U.S. 478
- 42 S. Ct. 164
- 66 L. Ed. 325
- 1922 U.S. LEXIS 2427
Syllabus
<p>1. Where the case as made by the bill involves a real and substantial question under the Constitution and the requisite jurisdictional amount, the jurisdiction of the District Court, and of this court upon a direct .review of its action, extends to all other questions involved, whether of federal or state law, and enables the court to rest its judgment on the decision of such of the questions as in its opinion effectually dispose of the case. P'. 482.</p> <p>2. Equity will enjoin collection of an illegal tax in the absence of an adequate and certain remedy at law. P. 482.</p> <p>■3. The Act of North Dakota, Laws 1919, c. 222, which lays an excise on foreign corporations of a percentage of their capital actually invested in the transaction of business in the State, provides that, for one engaged in business within and without the State, investment within the State shall mean that proportion of its entire. stock and bond issues which its intrastate business bears to its total business; that where the business within the State is not otherwise easily and certainly separable, it shall be held to mean such proportion of the entire business as the property of the corporation within the State bears to its entire property, and that, in the case of a railroad or other specified public service corporation, whose line extends into the State from without, property within the State shall mean the proportion of the entire property of the corporation which its mileage within the State bears to its entire mileage. Held, that the mileage basis (declared unconstitutional in Wallace v. Hines, 253 U. S. 66), was intended to be the exclusive basis for computing the assessments of such a railroad company, and that assessments based on the ratio of-the value of its railroad within the State to that of its entire railroad were not authorized by the statute. P. 482.</p> <p>4. The unconstitutionality of an excepting provision in a statute does not enlarge the scope of its other provisions
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- where an excepting provision is declared unconstitutional, preexisting law cannot be applied to persons within the exception
- where an excepting provision is declared unconstitutional, preexisting law cannot be applied to persons within the exception
- “Where an excepting provision in a statute is found unconstitutional, courts very generally hold that this does not work an enlargement of the scope or operation of other provisions with which that provision was enacted, and which it was intended to qualify or restrain”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Van Devanter
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
65 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Pennhurst State School and Hospital v. HaldermanSupreme Court· 1984-01-23· cited 8,956×
- Hagans v. LavineSupreme Court· 1974-03-25· cited 2,844×
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. ChadhaSupreme Court· 1983-06-23· cited 1,818×
- Perez v. LedesmaSupreme Court· 1971-02-23· cited 1,061×
- Hurn v. OurslerSupreme Court· 1933-04-17· cited 808×
- Matthews v. RodgersSupreme Court· 1932-02-15· cited 474×
- Rezi P. Forshey, Claimant-Appellant v. Anthony J. Principi, Secretary of Veterans AffairsFederal Circuit· 2002-04-01· cited 453×
- Frost v. Corporation Comm'n of Okla.Supreme Court· 1929-02-18· cited 389×
- Sterling v. ConstantinSupreme Court· 1932-12-12· cited 368×
- Legal Services Corp. v. VelazquezSupreme Court· 2001-02-28· cited 314×
- California Water Service Co. v. City of ReddingSupreme Court· 1938-05-16· cited 280×
- Anderson v. WoodTexas Supreme Court· 1941-05-14· cited 227×
- Douglas v. NobleSupreme Court· 1923-02-19· cited 164×
- Howard B. Quinn and Charlotte J. Quinn v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSeventh Circuit· 1975-10-17· cited 127×
- Southern Railway Co. v. WattsSupreme Court· 1923-01-02· cited 121×
- Lynden Transport, Inc. v. StateAlaska Supreme Court· 1975-02-24· cited 85×
- International Harvester Co. v. Wisconsin Dept. of TaxationSupreme Court· 1944-05-29· cited 85×
- Levering & Garrigues Co. v. MorrinSecond Circuit· 1932-08-23· cited 77×
- Gary v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1985-10-17· cited 68×
- Texas-Louisiana Power Co. v. City of FarmersvilleTexas Commission of Appeals· 1933-12-30· cited 66×
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named Davis v. Wallace
4 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.