David Chase v. Chris Stewart
Syllabus
A trial court held two attorneys in contempt, assessing damages and sanctions against them. Shortly before another hearing in which the court was to consider a supplemental award of attorney's fees, the judge of the trial court made comments in an unrelated case about one of the attorneys held in contempt. That attorney moved to recuse based, in part, on the judge's comments. The trial court denied the motion to recuse and later entered a supplemental order of damages against the attorneys. Because the judge's comments provide a reasonable basis for questioning his impartiality, we reverse the denial of the motion to recuse. And because retroactive recusal is appropriate, we also vacate the contempt and damages orders.
Judges: Judge W. Neal McBrayer
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
24 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Chapman v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1967-03-27· cited 23,069×
- In Re Murchison.Supreme Court· 1955-05-16· cited 2,510×
- United States v. Grinnell Corp.Supreme Court· 1966-06-13· cited 2,474×
- Liljeberg v. Health Services Acquisition Corp.Supreme Court· 1988-06-17· cited 1,932×
- Offutt v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1954-11-08· cited 1,331×
- Williams v. PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 2016-06-09· cited 380×
- Alley v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee· 1994-04-20· cited 376×
- State of Tennessee v. Kacy Dewayne CannonTennessee Supreme Court· 2008-04-29· cited 309×
- Davis v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2001-02-23· cited 257×
- State v. AustinTennessee Supreme Court· 2002-09-16· cited 197×
- Barnes v. Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2000-05-30· cited 151×
- Gary M. GOSSETT v. TRACTOR SUPPLY COMPANY, INC.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2010-09-20· cited 134×
- Van Tran v. StateTennessee Supreme Court· 2001-12-04· cited 118×
- James G. Thomas, Jr., Brother and Next of Kin of Karen G. Thomas v. Elizabeth Oldfield, M.D.Tennessee Supreme Court· 2009-02-02· cited 82×
- Wilson v. WilsonCourt of Appeals of Tennessee· 1998-09-02· cited 80×
- Leighton v. HendersonTennessee Supreme Court· 1967-04-07· cited 73×
- Bailey v. Blount County Board of EducationTennessee Supreme Court· 2010-01-28· cited 67×
- Arnold v. Morgan Keegan & Co., Inc.Tennessee Supreme Court· 1996-01-16· cited 58×
- State v. BensonTennessee Supreme Court· 1998-06-01· cited 41×
- Chumbley v. Peoples Bank & Trust Co.Tennessee Supreme Court· 1933-03-18· cited 41×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.