Chantangco v. Abaroa
Citations
- 218 U.S. 476
- 31 S. Ct. 34
- 54 L. Ed. 1116
- 1910 U.S. LEXIS 2042
Syllabus
<p>The general rule of the common law is that a judgment in a criminal proceeding cannot be read in evidence in a civil action to establish any fact there determined. The parties are not the same and different rules of evidence are applicable, .</p> <p>Identity of parties will not always operate to make a judgment in a criminal action admissible in a civil action; there must be identity of issue, Stone v. United States, 167 U. S. 178, although as held in Coffey v. United States, 116 U. S. 436, when the facts are ascertained in a criminal case as “between the United States and' the defendant they cannot be again litigated as between him and the United States • as the basis of any statutory punishment denounced as a consequence of the existence of the facts.</p> <p>In a case coming from the Philippine Islands, however, this court will not apply the common-law rule as to effect to be given in a subsequent civil case to a judgment in a criminal case, but will consider only whether the local law of the Philippine Islands has been rightly applied.</p> <p>The local law in the Philippine Islands, which is still in force, not having been suspended by legislation, is that indemnity for damages in penal cases is a consequence of the commission of the crime and a verdict of acquittal carries with it exemption from civil liability. This rule applies even against one who in the criminal action attempted to reserve his rights to bring a civil action.</p>
Judges: Lurton
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
35 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. One Assortment of 89 FirearmsSupreme Court· 1984-02-22· cited 720×
- Anderson v. City of PocatelloIdaho Supreme Court· 1987-01-28· cited 134×
- Murphy v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1926-12-06· cited 85×
- Estelle Jordan v. Lawrence MedleyD.C. Circuit· 1983-06-14· cited 82×
- Bluefields S. S. Co. v. United Fruit Co.Third Circuit· 1917-06-26· cited 80×
- Bowen ex rel. Doe v. ArnoldTennessee Supreme Court· 2016-06-02· cited 57×
- Der Minasian v. Aetna Life InsuranceMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1936-06-30· cited 41×
- Helvering v. MitchellSupreme Court· 1938-03-07· cited 31×
- Austin v. United StatesSeventh Circuit· 1942-02-16· cited 25×
- Hill v. MorrisSupreme Court of Florida· 1956-01-27· cited 22×
- New York Life Ins. Co. v. MurdaughFourth Circuit· 1938-01-11· cited 17×
- United States v. United States Gypsum Co.District of Columbia· 1943-08-10· cited 16×
- Mitchell v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSecond Circuit· 1937-05-10· cited 14×
- Basista v. WeirW.D. Pennsylvania· 1964-01-10· cited 13×
- Hammel v. LittleD.C. Circuit· 1936-12-14· cited 13×
- Clements v. PearsonTennessee Supreme Court· 1961-12-08· cited 12×
- Strachan Shipping Company v. SheaS.D. Texas· 1967-12-08· cited 10×
- Duncan v. StateSupreme Court of Georgia· 1919-06-14· cited 9×
- Fleischmann Malting Co. v. MrkacekSeventh Circuit· 1926-08-04· cited 9×
- Zucca v. United StatesCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1920-04-13· cited 6×
Cites
4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.