Burcica v. Ludy
Citations
- 2024 Ohio 6038
Syllabus
LANDLORD/TENANT — DAMAGES — ATTORNEY FEES: The trial court did not err in denying plaintiff landlord's full claim of damages where the landlord failed to sufficiently preserve her morning-of-trial request for additional damages, the trial court's finding of ordinary wear and tear was not against the manifest weight of the evidence, and the trial court's finding that the parties mutually agreed to terminate the lease was supported by the evidence. The trial court did not err in awarding damages to defendant tenant for moving expenses based on constructive eviction where the record shows that, despite the subsequent agreement reached between the landlord and tenant, the landlord's retaliatory conduct and breach of the peace were the acts that compelled the tenant to leave. The trial court did not err in awarding damages to the tenant for lost wages where the record credibly established that the landlord visited the tenant's workplace for the purposes of harassing her or trying to get her fired and the tenant left work due to the intrusion. [See CONCURRENCE: Proximate cause existed on the claim for lost wages based on the trial court's unchallenged finding that the tenant left work because the landlord showed up.] The trial court did not err in awarding damages to the tenant for intentional infliction of emotional distress where the court issued detailed findings in its judgment entry supporting the various elements of the tort of intentional infliction of emotional distress and the landlord neglected to challenge those findings or otherwise explain why they defied the manifest weight of the evidence. [But see DISSENT: The evidence presented was insufficient as a matter of law to support a claim of damages for intentional infliction of emotional distress where the tenant failed to present requisite evidence to act as a guarantee of the genuineness of her claim.] The trial court did not err in awarding damages to the tenant for rent abatement where the tenant testified
Judges: Bergeron
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
24 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. ThompkinsOhio Supreme Court· 1997-05-14· cited 16,183×
- Eastley v. VolkmanOhio Supreme Court· 2012-05-22· cited 2,407×
- Yeager v. Local Union 20, Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen & Helpers of AmericaOhio Supreme Court· 1983-08-31· cited 822×
- Strother v. HutchinsonOhio Supreme Court· 1981-07-22· cited 727×
- Preston v. MurtyOhio Supreme Court· 1987-09-09· cited 454×
- Paugh v. HanksOhio Supreme Court· 1983-07-27· cited 441×
- Schultz v. Barberton Glass Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 1983-04-13· cited 138×
- Smith v. PadgettOhio Supreme Court· 1987-09-16· cited 129×
- Uebelacker v. Cincom Systems, Inc.Ohio Court of Appeals· 1988-12-28· cited 120×
- Heiner v. MoretuzzoOhio Supreme Court· 1995-08-16· cited 114×
- Powell v. Grant Med. Ctr.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2002-02-05· cited 77×
- Cruz v. English Nanny & Governess School Inc.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2017-06-08· cited 18×
- Hensel v. ChildressOhio Court of Appeals· 2019-09-27· cited 14×
- Guthrie v. GuthrieOhio Court of Appeals· 2024-11-27· cited 13×
- Cincinnati v. Twang, L.L.C.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2021-12-15· cited 6×
- Mallory v. MalloryOhio Court of Appeals· 2024-11-20· cited 6×
- Germadnik v. AuldOhio Court of Appeals· 2018-07-23· cited 5×
- Risch v. SamuelOhio Court of Appeals· 2020-03-25· cited 5×
- Georgin v. GeorginOhio Court of Appeals· 2022-12-05· cited 5×
- Ellis v. SkinnerOhio Court of Appeals· 2022-12-30· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.