EPA v. GOODMAN OIL COMPANY AND GOODMAN OIL COMPANY OF LEWISTON

Case summary

After a six-day administrative hearing in 2001, the ALJ issued an Initial Decision on January 30, 2003 ordering Goodman Oil to pay a $105,716 penalty and Goodman Lewiston to pay a $88,276 penalty. The ALJ also ordered Goodman Oil to correct UST violations at six gas stations and Goodman Lewiston to respond to an information request concerning the locations and status of it's USTs. The Companies did not appeal the Initial Decision, which then became final on May 30, 2003. The Companies were required to pay the penalties and comply with the final order by July 29, 2003. They have not done so even after an EPA demand letter was sent to them. This referral seeks collection of the penalty plus additional non-compliance penalties and a district court order compelling the companies to comply with the final order

Defendants (1)

• GOODMAN OIL COMPANY AND GOODMAN OIL COMPANY OF LEWNamed in complaintNamed in settlement

Facilities (9)

• GOODMAN OIL CO OF LEWISTON

  501 SNAKE RIVER AVE, LEWISTON, ID, 835012262

  Registry ID: 110010589915

• CAPITAL EXXON

  1265 S CAPITAL BLVD, BOISE, ID, 837063016

  Registry ID: 110010780690

• MOUNTAIN MART EXXN/GOODMAN OIL

  102 THAIN RD, LEWISTON, ID, 835012262

  Registry ID: 110005784311

• WEISER EXXON

  205 E MAIN ST, WEISER, ID, 836722536

  Registry ID: 110010588202

• COLLISTER EXXON

  4780 W STATE ST, BOISE, ID, 837036075

  Registry ID: 110010780716

• EXXON

  1522 W STATE ST, BOISE, ID, 837020417

  Registry ID: 110010780681

• NAMPA EXXON

  920 2ND ST S, NAMPA, ID, 83651

  Registry ID: 110010780707

• TIGER MART #5

  3201 5TH ST, LEWISTON, ID, 835012262

  Registry ID: 110010589924

• TIGER MART EXXON

  120 S MAIN ST, HOMEDALE, ID, 836283420

  Registry ID: 110010589933

Statutes cited

• RCRA 9005 — Inspections, Monitoring, Testing, Corrective Actions
• RCRA 9003 — UST Release Detection, Prevention, Correction Regulations

Enforcement conclusions (1)

• GOODMAN OIL COMPANY AND GOODMAN OIL COMPANY OF LEWISTONentered 2010-10-01

  Primary law: RCRA

  Federal penalty: $171,091

Timeline (8 milestones)

• 2003-09-30Referred To Dept Of Justice
• 2003-10-01Enforcement Action Data Entered
• 2010-09-29Complaint Filed With Court
• 2010-09-29Final Order Lodged
• 2010-10-01Concluded
• 2010-10-01Final Order Entered
• 2010-10-01Formal Action to Collect Penalty
• 2012-06-04Enforcement Action Closed