Federal Circuit· 4/16/2008
Zenith Electronics Corp. v. PDI Communication Systems, Inc.
Citations
- 522 F.3d 1348
- 86 U.S.P.Q. 2d (BNA) 1513
- 2008 U.S. App. LEXIS 8128
- 2008 WL 1734195
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a combination of printed schematics and expert testimony on a product was permissible and indeed sufficient to prove anticipation
- explaining that finding of invalidity of certain claims does not moot counterclaim for inequitable conduct directed to entire patent
- “Anticipation requires a showing that each element of the claim, properly construed, is found in a single prior art reference.”
- “It is the presence of the prior art and its relationship to the claim language that matters for invalidity”
- “[M]ere proof that the prior art is identical, in all material respects, to an allegedly infringing product cannot constitute clear and convincing evidence of invalidity.”
- “[M]ere proof that the prior art is identical, in all material respects, to an allegedly infringing product cannot constitute clear and convincing evidence of invalidity.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Newman, Lourie, and Schall, Circuit Judges
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
48 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- I4i Ltd. Partnership v. Microsoft Corp.Federal Circuit· 2010-03-10· cited 374×
- Uniloc USA, Inc. v. Microsoft Corp.Federal Circuit· 2011-01-04· cited 236×
- Verizon Services Corp. v. Cox Fibernet Virginia, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2010-04-16· cited 58×
- Osram Sylvania, Inc. v. American Induction Technologies, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2012-12-13· cited 38×
- Microsoft Corporation v. Geotag, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2016-04-01· cited 35×
- Cornell University v. Hewlett-Packard Co.N.D. New York· 2009-03-30· cited 28×
- Lucent Technologies, Inc. v. Board of EqualizationCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2015-10-08· cited 23×
- Cordance Corp. v. Amazon. Com, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2011-09-23· cited 20×
- Touchcom, Inc. v. Bereskin & ParrE.D. Virginia· 2011-07-07· cited 17×
- 01 Communique Laboratory, Inc v. Citrix Online, LLCFederal Circuit· 2018-04-26· cited 17×
- Silver State Intellectual Technologies, Inc. v. Garmin International, Inc.D. Nevada· 2014-07-24· cited 15×
- Rowe International Corp. v. Ecast, Inc.N.D. Illinois· 2008-08-25· cited 14×
- Icon-IP Pty Ltd. v. Specialized Bicycle Components, Inc.N.D. California· 2015-03-31· cited 14×
- Nextec Applications v. BROOKWOOD COMPANIES, INC.S.D. New York· 2010-03-31· cited 10×
- I4i Ltd. Partnership v. Microsoft Corp.Federal Circuit· 2009-12-22· cited 9×
- Minemyer v. B-Roc Representatives, Inc.N.D. Illinois· 2009-10-27· cited 7×
- Sensormatic Electronics Corp. v. TAG CO. US, LLCS.D. Florida· 2008-12-19· cited 6×
- Sunoco Partners Mktg. v. U.S. Venture, Inc.E.D. Illinois· 2018-10-06· cited 5×
- Liquidating Trustee Ester Duval of KI Liquidation, Inc. v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2009-08-11· cited 4×
- Kaneka Corp. v. SKC Kolon PI, Inc.C.D. California· 2016-08-02· cited 4×
Cites
27 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.Supreme Court· 1986-06-25· cited 135,235×
- Adickes v. S. H. Kress & Co.Supreme Court· 1970-06-01· cited 15,427×
- Edward H. Phillips v. Awh Corporation, Hopeman Brothers, Inc., and Lofton Corporation, Defendants-CrossFederal Circuit· 2006-02-21· cited 3,273×
- Cybor Corporation v. Fas Technologies, Inc., and Fastar Ltd., Defendants-CrossFederal Circuit· 1998-03-25· cited 1,536×
- Sri International v. Matsushita Electric Corporation of America and Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd.Federal Circuit· 1985-10-16· cited 787×
- Teleflex, Inc. v. Ficosa North America Corp., Fico Cables, S.A., and Ficosa North America S.A. De C.V.Federal Circuit· 2002-08-30· cited 652×
- Kingsdown Medical Consultants, Ltd. And E.R. Squibb & Sons, Inc. v. Hollister IncorporatedFederal Circuit· 1988-12-21· cited 553×
- Telemac Cellular Corporation v. Topp Telecom, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2001-04-25· cited 267×
- United States v. Univis Lens Co.Supreme Court· 1942-05-11· cited 227×
- Vincent J. Krocka, Cross-Appellee v. City of Chicago, an Illinois Municipal CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2000-02-08· cited 182×
- Bandag, Inc., Appellee/cross-Appellant. v. Al Bolser's Tire Stores, Inc., Appellant/cross-AppelleeFederal Circuit· 1984-11-08· cited 178×
- General Electric Company v. Nintendo Company, Ltd. And Nintendo of America, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1999-06-02· cited 149×
- Tate Access Floors, Inc. And Tate Access Floors Leasing, Inc. v. Interface Architectural Resources, Inc.Federal Circuit· 2002-02-07· cited 145×
- Met-Coil Systems Corporation v. Korners Unlimited, Inc. And Ductmate Industries, Inc.Federal Circuit· 1986-10-08· cited 132×
- Nazomi Communications, Inc. v. Arm Holdings, PlcFederal Circuit· 2005-04-11· cited 125×
- Fort James Corporation v. Solo Cup CompanyFederal Circuit· 2005-06-22· cited 123×
- Wilson Sporting Goods Company v. Hillerich & Bradsby Co.Federal Circuit· 2006-03-23· cited 95×
- Saab Cars Usa, Inc. v. United States, Defendant-CrossFederal Circuit· 2006-01-17· cited 85×
- Liebel-Flarsheim Company and Mallinckrodt, Inc. v. Medrad, Inc., Defendant-CrossFederal Circuit· 2007-03-22· cited 77×
- Jerry Gechter, Robert L. Pokress, Jeffrey A. Fried, and G. Wayne Andrews v. Wayne A. Davidson and Diana S. WinterFederal Circuit· 1997-06-12· cited 74×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.