William Jenkins, as the personal representative of the Estate of Carl Grant v. City of Birmingham, Randall Woodfin, Scott Thurmond, Clinton Woods, Hunter Williams, Valerie Abbott, Jonathan T. Moore, Darrell O'Quinn, Crystal Smitherman, Wardine Alexander, Carol Clarke, Latanya Tate, and Vincent Larry (Appeal from Jefferson Circuit Court: CV-22-902083; Civil Appeals: CL-2024-0063).