Werner v. Zierfuss
Citations
- 162 Pa. 360
- 29 A. 737
- 1894 Pa. LEXIS 988
Syllabus
<p>Conveyance in fraud of creditors- — Antecedent debt — Evidence.</p> <p>If a creditor takes a judgment, or conveyance, or payment in any form, to secure an actual debt, the transaction will be valid against other creditors, although he knew that the effect would be to postpone the others ; that the debtor intended it to have that effect; and although he took it to aid that effect as well as to protect himself. The criterion is not the effect but the fraudulent intent.</p> <p>It follows that where there is an actual debt the jury cannot be permitted to infer a fraudulent intent from the mere fact of payment or preference given to it.</p> <p>To impeach the payment or securing of an actual debt'there should be evidence tending to show either, first, some advantage or benefit to the debtor beyond the discharge of his obligation; or, secondly, some other benefit to the creditor beyond mere payment of his debt; or, lastly, some injury to the other creditors beyond mere postponement to the debt preferred.</p>
Judges: Dean, Fell, Green, Mitchell, Sterrett
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
13 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Peoples-Pittsburgh Trust Co. v. Holy Family Polish National Catholic ChurchSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1941-04-14· cited 5×
- Whitman v. O'BrienSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1905-10-09· cited 5×
- McCartney v. EarleThird Circuit· 1902-04-21· cited 4×
- Braden v. O'NeilSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1898-01-03· cited 2×
- Borough of Verona v. Allegheny Valley Railway Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1898-10-17· cited 1×
- Dalley's EstateSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1900-04-30· cited 1×
- Gump v. McDanielSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1910-04-18· cited 1×
- In re A. L. Robertshaw Mfg. Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1904-12-05· cited 1×
- Lasher v. Medical Press Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-02-16
- Meyers v. MeyersSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-04-18
- Emerick v. BrauchtCentre County Court of Common Pleas· 1928-08-15
- Bell Telephone Co. v. SchwabPhiladelphia County Court of Common Pleas· 1938-08-22
- Getz v. HarleyMontgomery County Court of Common Pleas· 1949-07-21
Cites
7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Lake Shore Banking Co. v. FullerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1885-10-05· cited 14×
- Covanhovan v. HartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1853-09-08· cited 13×
- York County Bank v. CarterSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1861-03-11· cited 11×
- Bentz v. RockeySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1872-05-11· cited 10×
- Uhler v. MaulfairSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1854-07-01· cited 5×
- Bunn, Raiguel & Co. v. AhlSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1857-07-01· cited 5×
- Bear's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1869-02-04· cited 5×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.