Ohio Supreme Court· 5/31/1995
Vail v. Plain Dealer Publishing Co.
Citations
- 72 Ohio St. 3d 279
- 649 N.E.2d 182
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that a value-laden statement that creates only a veiled suggestion that its subject is mendacious is properly deemed a statement of opinion, not of fact
- deciding that a columnist’s accusations that a candidate engaged in “anti- homosexual diatribe” and fostered homophobia “can hardly be defined with crystal clarity,” and were “value-laden” and “subjective”
- holding that alleg edly defamatory statements were protected opinion, and concluding that since “the statements at issue are constitutionally protected speech, [the plaintiffs] claims for intentional infliction of emotional distress must also fail.”
- finding that article appearing in \Commentary\ column within the \Forum\ page of the newspaper led to the conclusion that the general context of the article is opinion
- finding that a column that appeared on the Forum page of the newspaper and titled \Commentary\ gave a reader the message that the column would convey the personal opinion of the writer, as distinguished from a news story
- noting that the column appeared on the Forum page of the newspaper, and that the words “forum” and “commentary” “convey a message that the reader of columns so designated will be exposed to the personal opinions of the writer”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cook, Douglas, Moyer, Only, Pfeifer, Resnick, Sweeney, Wright
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
89 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- A & B-Abell Elevator Co. v. Columbus/Central Ohio Building & Construction Trades CouncilOhio Supreme Court· 1995-08-02· cited 323×
- Johnson v. Microsoft Corp.Ohio Supreme Court· 2005-10-05· cited 194×
- Harris v. BornhorstSixth Circuit· 2008-01-14· cited 184×
- Volbers-Klarich v. Middletown Management, Inc.Ohio Supreme Court· 2010-05-18· cited 167×
- Randolph L. Cook v. Oprah WinfreySeventh Circuit· 1998-04-08· cited 133×
- Desenco, Inc. v. City of AkronOhio Supreme Court· 1999-03-10· cited 127×
- Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co. v. Public Utilities CommissionOhio Supreme Court· 1996-08-21· cited 117×
- Wampler v. HigginsOhio Supreme Court· 2001-08-29· cited 109×
- McKimm v. Ohio Elections CommissionOhio Supreme Court· 2000-06-14· cited 80×
- Federated Management Co. v. Coopers & LybrandOhio Court of Appeals· 2000-04-04· cited 77×
- Portia Boulger v. James WoodsSixth Circuit· 2019-02-27· cited 69×
- A & B-Abell Elevator Co. v. Columbus/Cent. Ohio Bldg. & Constr. Trades CouncilOhio Supreme Court· 1995-08-02· cited 68×
- Beilenson v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1996-04-24· cited 67×
- Maitland v. Ford Motor Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 2004-11-10· cited 67×
- Neumann v. LilesOregon Supreme Court· 2016-03-03· cited 64×
- Bentkowski v. Scene MagazineSixth Circuit· 2011-04-19· cited 57×
- Office of Disciplinary Counsel v. GardnerOhio Supreme Court· 2003-08-13· cited 47×
- McCaskill v. Gallaudet UniversityDistrict of Columbia· 2014-04-14· cited 39×
- Vail v. The Plain Dealer Publishing Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 1995-05-31· cited 34×
- Gilson v. Am. Inst. of Alternative MedicineOhio Court of Appeals· 2016-03-29· cited 31×
Cites
9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- New York Times Co. v. SullivanSupreme Court· 1964-03-09· cited 8,531×
- Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co.Supreme Court· 1990-06-21· cited 1,770×
- Mitchell v. Lawson Milk Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 1988-12-30· cited 945×
- Philadelphia Newspapers, Inc. v. HeppsSupreme Court· 1986-04-21· cited 858×
- Bertell Ollman v. Rowland Evans, Robert NovakD.C. Circuit· 1984-12-06· cited 402×
- Arnold v. City of ClevelandOhio Supreme Court· 1993-08-11· cited 279×
- Scott v. News-HeraldOhio Supreme Court· 1986-08-06· cited 207×
- Grau v. KleinschmidtOhio Supreme Court· 1987-06-24· cited 106×
- Varanese v. GallOhio Supreme Court· 1988-02-03· cited 71×
Other cases named Vail v. Plain Dealer Publishing Co.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.