First Circuit· 1/5/2006
United States v. Pho
Citations
- 433 F.3d 53
- 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 153
- 2006 WL 20574
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that such \error[s] of law\ are reviewed de novo and render a sentence \per se unreasonable\
- recognizing that variances may not be based upon “general disagreement with broad-based policies enunciated by Congress or the Commission, as its agent.”
- holding that district court could not impose a sentence outside advisory Guideline range based solely on rejection of Guidelines' disparate treatment of crack and powder cocaine
- rejecting a variety of arguments against the ratio, including those based on the Sentencing Commission’s effort to ease the discrepancy
- holding, post-Booker, “a district court may exercise discretion in fashioning sentences — but that discretion was meant to operate only within the ambit of the individualized factors spelled out in section 3553(a),” and though broad, that discretion is not limitless
- “Although the district court’s approach does ameliorate the disparity in sentences for crack and powdered cocaine offenses ... Congress intended that particular disparity to exist, and federal courts are not free to second-guess that type of decision.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Selya, Lipez, Howard
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
89 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Kimbrough v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2007-12-10· cited 3,379×
- United States v. Johnny GunterThird Circuit· 2006-09-11· cited 572×
- United States v. JonesSecond Circuit· 2008-06-24· cited 294×
- United States v. WilliamsEleventh Circuit· 2006-07-21· cited 268×
- United States v. Vincent Carnelius Eura, United States of America v. Vincent Carnelius EuraFourth Circuit· 2006-02-24· cited 154×
- United States v. DixonFirst Circuit· 2006-05-26· cited 142×
- United States v. Jimenez-BeltreFirst Circuit· 2006-03-09· cited 140×
- United States v. Taryll MillerSeventh Circuit· 2006-06-07· cited 140×
- United States v. LeahyFirst Circuit· 2012-02-03· cited 127×
- United States v. McCulloughTenth Circuit· 2006-08-10· cited 110×
- Conteh v. GonzalesFirst Circuit· 2006-08-22· cited 93×
- United States v. CaraballoFirst Circuit· 2008-12-22· cited 93×
- United States v. DuhonFifth Circuit· 2006-02-17· cited 92×
- United States v. JimenezFirst Circuit· 2007-12-27· cited 87×
- United States v. GilmanFirst Circuit· 2007-03-08· cited 83×
- United States v. Miguel Tzep-MejiaFifth Circuit· 2006-08-15· cited 80×
- United States v. Garcia-CarrasquilloFirst Circuit· 2007-04-03· cited 70×
- United States v. SmithFirst Circuit· 2006-04-07· cited 65×
- United States v. Juan CastilloSecond Circuit· 2006-08-16· cited 63×
- United States v. RodriguezFirst Circuit· 2008-06-04· cited 60×
Cites
31 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. BookerSupreme Court· 2004-10-01· cited 23,210×
- Koon v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1996-06-13· cited 3,761×
- Mistretta v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1989-01-18· cited 2,457×
- United States v. Jerome CrosbySecond Circuit· 2005-02-02· cited 1,342×
- United States v. AntonakopoulosFirst Circuit· 2005-02-22· cited 313×
- United States v. William A. DietzFirst Circuit· 1991-11-27· cited 246×
- United States v. EvansSupreme Court· 1948-05-03· cited 217×
- United States v. John L. St. CyrFirst Circuit· 1992-10-15· cited 188×
- United States v. Andrew FagansSecond Circuit· 2005-04-27· cited 177×
- United States v. GracianiFirst Circuit· 1995-07-24· cited 134×
- Plumley v. Southern Container, Inc.First Circuit· 2002-09-13· cited 101×
- United States v. Joseph GeranteFirst Circuit· 1989-12-21· cited 97×
- United States v. Daryl E. SingleterryFirst Circuit· 1994-07-18· cited 91×
- United States v. Colon-SolisFirst Circuit· 2004-01-08· cited 90×
- United States v. SnyderFirst Circuit· 1998-02-13· cited 69×
- United States v. Angel SanchezFirst Circuit· 1996-04-08· cited 62×
- United States v. RobinsonFirst Circuit· 1998-05-08· cited 61×
- United States v. MatosFirst Circuit· 2003-05-07· cited 61×
- United States v. AndradeFirst Circuit· 1996-08-26· cited 59×
- United States v. EirbyFirst Circuit· 2001-08-29· cited 55×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.