Sixth Circuit· 9/13/2013
United States v. Marcus Freeman
Citations
- 730 F.3d 590
- 92 Fed. R. Serv. 507
- 2013 WL 4863790
- 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 18976
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that Rule 701 barred an officer’s testimony which essentially “spoon-fed his interpretations of the phone calls and the government’s theory of the case to the jury, interpreting even ordinary English language”
- explaining that lay witnesses may not provide opinions regarding events outside of their personal perception
- stating that law enforcement officer testifying as lay witness may not explain to jury what inferences to draw from evidence that is within jury’s competence to understand and decide
- disapproving of law enforcement experts “spoon-feeding” their own interpretations of “ordinary English language” to the jury
- finding a witness’ opinions which address matters which are within the jurors’ competence to understand and decide is not helpful and therefore inadmissible
- describing split among the circuits on this issue, with the Second and D.C. Circuit disagreeing with the Eleventh Circuit
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cole, Cook, Katz
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
39 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- People v. McFeeColorado Court of Appeals· 2016-06-30· cited 551×
- United States v. Anthony GadsonNinth Circuit· 2014-08-19· cited 157×
- United States v. Kwame KilpatrickSixth Circuit· 2015-08-14· cited 127×
- United States v. YoungSixth Circuit· 2017-01-26· cited 125×
- United States v. Clarence HainesFifth Circuit· 2015-10-15· cited 112×
- United States v. Rahman FultonThird Circuit· 2016-09-19· cited 73×
- United States v. Keli DunnicanSixth Circuit· 2020-06-09· cited 72×
- United States v. Dominique JacksonThird Circuit· 2017-02-24· cited 63×
- State v. HymanNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 2017-08-16· cited 63×
- King Bradley, Jr. v. Ameristep, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 2015-08-24· cited 53×
- United States v. Anthony WilloughbySixth Circuit· 2014-01-30· cited 44×
- United States v. Brittan KettlesSixth Circuit· 2020-08-12· cited 36×
- United States v. David MinerSixth Circuit· 2014-12-12· cited 35×
- United States v. James Maarvin HawkinsEleventh Circuit· 2019-08-20· cited 34×
- Commonwealth v. RoseSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-09-29· cited 33×
- United States v. HillFifth Circuit· 2023-03-22· cited 33×
- United States v. Shane FloydSixth Circuit· 2017-09-29· cited 25×
- United States v. Gene HowellSixth Circuit· 2021-11-08· cited 18×
- United States v. Sandra WhiteSixth Circuit· 2017-01-13· cited 15×
- United States v. Kelli PratherSixth Circuit· 2025-05-27· cited 14×
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Kumho Tire Co. v. CarmichaelSupreme Court· 1999-03-23· cited 8,651×
- United States v. YoungSupreme Court· 1985-02-20· cited 4,689×
- United States v. WhiteSixth Circuit· 2007-06-11· cited 268×
- United States v. MirandaFifth Circuit· 2001-04-17· cited 254×
- United States v. Luis Lopez-MedinaSixth Circuit· 2006-08-25· cited 250×
- United States v. JayyousiEleventh Circuit· 2011-09-19· cited 202×
- United States v. JohnsonFourth Circuit· 2010-08-16· cited 201×
- United States v. RollinsSeventh Circuit· 2008-09-15· cited 180×
- United States v. FreemanNinth Circuit· 2007-08-20· cited 143×
- United States v. Cornelius Peoples, United States of America v. Xavier LightfootEighth Circuit· 2001-05-18· cited 110×
- United States v. OriedoSeventh Circuit· 2007-08-06· cited 108×
- United States of America, Plaintif-Appellant v. Albert Ganier, IIISixth Circuit· 2006-11-15· cited 89×
- McGowan v. Cooper Industries, Inc.Sixth Circuit· 1988-12-20· cited 63×
- United States v. Flavio David MendozaNinth Circuit· 2001-03-29· cited 48×
- United States v. Jerome HamptonD.C. Circuit· 2013-06-25· cited 42×
- United States v. AlbertelliFirst Circuit· 2012-06-29· cited 35×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.