United States v. Field
Citations
- 255 U.S. 257
Syllabus
<p>1. The provisions of laws imposing taxes are not to be extended by implication. P. 262.</p> <p>2. The Revenue Act of 1916, § 202, c. 463,39 Stat. 777, did not impose an estate tax upon'property passing under a testamentary execution of a general power of appointment. Id.</p> <p>3. To be taxable under clause (a) of § 202 of the act, the estate must' be (1) an interest of the decedent at the time of his death, (2) which, after his death, is subject to the payment of the charges against . his estate and the expenses of administration, and (3)' is subject to distribution as part of his estate; and these conditions are expressed conjunctively and cannot be construed as disjunctive. Id.</p> <p>4. A general power of appointment by will does not of itself vest any estate in the donee of the power. P. 263.</p> <p>5. In equity, property passing under such a power-may be treated as assets of the donee-of the power, distributable.to his creditors, but only when the power has been executed, and executed in favor of a . volunteer, and then only to the extent to which- the donee’s own estate is insufficient to pay his debts; and his executor, if he take the appointed property at all, takes not as executor but as representative of the creditors. Id.</p> <p>6. In any event, the property subject to such a power is not subject to distribution as part of the estate of the donee. . P. 264.</p> <p>7. Clause '(b) of § 202 of the act, describing a transfer of an interest in the decedent’s own property in his lifetime, intended to take effect at or after his death, does not cover a transfer by testamentary execution of a power of appointment over property not his own. Id.</p> <p>8. The fact that in-the later Act of February 24, 1919, property passing under a general power of appointment executed by the deceased was expressly included in the valuation of his estate for taxation, shows at least a legislative doubt whether the Act of 1916 included such property. P. 265.'</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- “These conditions are expressed conjunc-tively; and it would be inadmissible, in construing a taxing act, to read them as if prescribed disjunctively.”
- “These conditions are expressed conjunctively; and it would be inadmissible, in construing a taxing act, to read them as if prescribed disjunctively.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Pitney
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
100 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Crooks v. HarrelsonSupreme Court· 1930-11-24· cited 616×
- Burnet v. GuggenheimSupreme Court· 1933-02-06· cited 348×
- Curry v. McCanlessSupreme Court· 1939-05-29· cited 320×
- Porter v. CommissionerSupreme Court· 1933-03-13· cited 251×
- Helvering v. Safe Deposit & Trust Co. of BaltimoreSupreme Court· 1942-04-13· cited 142×
- United States v. FieldSupreme Court· 1921-02-28· cited 104×
- Aluminum Castings Co. v. RoutzahnSupreme Court· 1930-11-24· cited 101×
- Officemax, Inc. v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 2005-11-02· cited 100×
- Estate of Harrison P. Shedd, Deceased First National Bank of Arizona, Phoenix v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueFirst Circuit· 1956-11-13· cited 56×
- Smietanka, Collector of Internal Revenue v. First Trust & Savings BankSupreme Court· 1921-11-21· cited 47×
- In Re Estate of BreaultIllinois Supreme Court· 1963-09-27· cited 47×
- Porter v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSecond Circuit· 1932-07-18· cited 45×
- Wachovia Bank & Trust Co. v. DoughtonSupreme Court· 1926-11-29· cited 35×
- Richardson v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSecond Circuit· 1941-07-09· cited 33×
- Estate of NewtonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1950-09-07· cited 32×
- Hogarth-Swann v. WeedMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1931-01-07· cited 32×
- Doll v. CommissionerEighth Circuit· 1945-04-24· cited 28×
- Eaton v. English & Mersick Co.Second Circuit· 1925-04-13· cited 24×
- Henigbaum v. ScottCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1955-09-08· cited 23×
- Hernandez v. BeckerTenth Circuit· 1931-12-07· cited 22×
Cites
4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Other cases named United States v. Field
42 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- United States v. FieldSupreme Court· 1921-02-28· cited 104×
- United States v. FieldS.D. New York· 1977-04-22· cited 54×
- United States v. FieldSecond Circuit· 1952-01-07· cited 51×
- United States v. FieldFirst Circuit· 1994-11-04· cited 40×
- United States v. FieldEighth Circuit· 1995-08-07· cited 36×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1927-02-24· cited 25×
- United States v. FieldW.D. Wisconsin· 1994-06-09· cited 23×
- United States v. FieldUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1955-01-07· cited 22×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1927-03-09· cited 18×
- United States v. FieldSecond Circuit· 1951-10-30· cited 16×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1927-06-10· cited 15×
- United States v. FieldSecond Circuit· 1951-07-17· cited 13×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1925-03-06· cited 13×
- United States v. FieldSecond Circuit· 1978-04-24· cited 11×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1917-01-22· cited 8×
- United States v. FieldSupreme Court· 1958-06-23· cited 7×
- United States v. FieldD. Minnesota· 1994-11-17· cited 6×
- United States v. FieldUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1953-07-31· cited 6×
- United States v. FieldU S Air Force Court of Military Review· 1992-11-19· cited 5×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1927-11-14· cited 3×
- United States v. FieldU.S. Circuit Court· 1883-05-15· cited 2×
- United States v. FieldSeventh Circuit· 1893-02-11· cited 2×
- United States v. FieldFifth Circuit· 1976-06-28· cited 1×
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1926-02-25· cited 1×
- United States v. FieldD. Wyoming· 1960-12-21· cited 1×
- United States v. FieldSeventh Circuit· 1896-01-06· cited 1×
- United States v. FieldEleventh Circuit· 1991-06-25
- United States v. FieldEleventh Circuit· 1997-07-16
- United States v. FieldFirst Circuit· 1994-11-04
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1929-04-02
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1929-11-04
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1929-12-30
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1930-11-10
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1931-02-03
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1931-03-25
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1932-01-25
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1932-05-02
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1933-10-30
- United States v. FieldCustoms and Patent Appeals· 1935-01-07
- United States v. FieldSupreme Court· 1921-02-28
- United States v. FieldSupreme Court· 1958-06-23
- United States v. FieldFifth Circuit· 1970-09-17
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.