Arizona Supreme Court· 1/25/2010
Turken v. Gordon
Citations
- 224 P.3d 158
- 223 Ariz. 342
- 574 Ariz. Adv. Rep. 17
- 2010 Ariz. LEXIS 7
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that, in the context of the constitution’s gift clause, a “forbidden subsidy” is demonstrated by the difference between a public expenditure and what is received in return
- stating that to comply with the Gift Clause, a governmental entity must receive consideration in return for expenditure that “is not so inequitable and unreasonable that it amounts to an abuse of discretion”
- analyzing the “Gift Clause” under article 9, section 7 of the Arizona Constitution which forbids corporate subsides
- prospective application is appropriate when a ruling overturns settled precedent, establishes a new legal principle, or would produce inequitable results if retroactively applied
- “The term consideration has a settled meaning in contract law. It is a performance or return promise that is bargained for in exchange for the promise of the other party.”
- describing commonalities between Gift and Taxation Clauses
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hurwitz, Berch, Ryan, Bales, Pelander
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
18 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Hall v. Elected Officials' Retirement PlanArizona Supreme Court· 2016-11-10· cited 17×
- Haugland v. City of BismarckNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 2012-07-06· cited 16×
- CNL Hotels & Resorts, Inc. v. Maricopa CountyArizona Supreme Court· 2012-07-03· cited 14×
- Ulrich v. Walker (In Re Boates)Ninth Circuit· 2016-06-09· cited 11×
- cheatham/huey v. Diciccio/phoenix Law Enforcement AssociationArizona Supreme Court· 2016-09-13· cited 11×
- Darcie Schires v. Cathy CarlatArizona Supreme Court· 2021-02-08· cited 5×
- Craig v. CraigCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2010-10-28· cited 3×
- Reep v. StateNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 2013-12-26· cited 3×
- Cheatham v. DiciccioCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2015-08-11· cited 2×
- Mark Gilmore v. Kate GallegoArizona Supreme Court· 2024-07-31· cited 1×
- cheatham/huey v. PleaCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2015-08-11
- Hon. Hall v. eorp/stateArizona Supreme Court· 2016-11-10
- In re: Craighton Thomas BoatesNinth Circuit· 2016-06-09
- State of Arizona v. Emilio JeanArizona Supreme Court· 2018-01-03
- Brush & Nib v. City of PhoenixArizona Supreme Court· 2019-09-16
- State of Arizona Ex Rel Brnovich v. AborArizona Supreme Court· 2020-11-25
- Gilmore v. GallegoCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2023-04-18
- Neptune Swimming Foundation v. City of ScottsdaleArizona Supreme Court· 2024-02-06
Cites
22 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Wagenseller v. Scottsdale Memorial HospitalArizona Supreme Court· 1985-11-27· cited 506×
- Schade v. DiethrichArizona Supreme Court· 1988-09-20· cited 96×
- Lowing v. Allstate InsuranceArizona Supreme Court· 1993-09-14· cited 83×
- Kotterman v. KillianArizona Supreme Court· 1999-01-26· cited 75×
- Fain Land & Cattle Co. v. HassellArizona Supreme Court· 1990-03-30· cited 53×
- Wistuber v. Paradise Valley Unified School DistrictArizona Supreme Court· 1984-06-20· cited 46×
- City of Tombstone v. MacIaArizona Supreme Court· 1926-04-24· cited 45×
- Industrial Develop. Auth. of Cty. of Pinal v. NelsonArizona Supreme Court· 1973-05-07· cited 40×
- City of Glendale v. WhiteArizona Supreme Court· 1948-06-01· cited 40×
- Day v. Buckeye Water Conservation & Drainage DistrictArizona Supreme Court· 1925-06-30· cited 33×
- State v. Northwestern Mutual Insurance CompanyArizona Supreme Court· 1959-06-04· cited 29×
- Bailey v. MyersCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2003-10-01· cited 27×
- Town of Gila Bend v. Walled Lake Door CompanyArizona Supreme Court· 1971-11-12· cited 26×
- City of Tempe v. Pilot Properties, Inc.Court of Appeals of Arizona· 1974-10-24· cited 25×
- Fickes v. Missoula CountyMontana Supreme Court· 1970-06-04· cited 21×
- City of Phoenix v. Superior Court of Maricopa CountyArizona Supreme Court· 1946-12-11· cited 21×
- Kromko v. Arizona Board of RegentsArizona Supreme Court· 1986-04-28· cited 20×
- Proctor v. HuntArizona Supreme Court· 1934-02-26· cited 14×
- Heiner v. City of MesaCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 1973-11-01· cited 11×
- Maricopa County v. StateCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 1996-07-11· cited 10×
Other cases named Turken v. Gordon
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.