Trump v. Vance
Citations
- 591 U.S. 786
- 140 S. Ct. 2412
- 207 L. Ed. 2d 907
About this case
Trump v. Vance
Trump v. Vance, 591 U.S. 786 (2020), was a landmark [1] [2] United States Supreme Court case arising from a subpoena issued in August 2019 by Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. against Mazars , then-President Donald Trump 's accounting firm, for Trump's tax records and related documents, as part of his ongoing investigation into the Stormy Daniels scandal . Trump commenced legal proceedings to prevent their release.
The Court held that Article II and the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution do not categorically preclude or require a heightened standard for the issuance of a state criminal subpoena to a sitting president.[3] The 7–2 decision was issued in July 2020, with Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissenting .[1]
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trump_v._Vance&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
Main articles: Tax returns of Donald Trump ; Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP ; and List of lawsuits involving Donald Trump
After Donald Trump indicated his intent to run for U.S. president as a Republican candidate, he was called upon to release his income tax returns in the public interest, as most other presidential candidates did. Trump had stated in his campaign that he would release them once they had been "worked on."[4] After his election victory and taking office in 2017, Trump refused to give over his tax records and stated that voters were not interested in them.[5]
The Democratic Party gained control of the U.S. House of Representatives in the 2018 midterm elections, and by April 2019, the House Ways and Means Committee had formally requested from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) six years of Trump's returns, a power vested in Congress under 26 U.S.C. § 6103 .[6] [7] [8] The IRS failed to comply with the request. Both the Ways and Means Committee and the House Committee on Oversight and Reform filed subpoenas to Mazars , Trump's accounting firm, to obtain the tax information. The Trump administration refused to comply with the subpoenas and asserted that they lacked "a legitimate legislative purpose."[9] [10] [11] However, those subpoenas were directed at Mazars and later at Deutsche Bank and Capital One , where Trump had accounts, and those entities had indicated they would comply with the subpoenas. Trump then tried to block the subpoenas, which led to two separate suits, _Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP _ and Trump et al. v. Deutsche Bank AG, which were consolidated under the Trump v. Mazars suit by the Supreme Court in its 2019 term.
District Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trump_v._Vance&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: District Court")
Separately, as part of the city's ongoing criminal investigation into the Stormy Daniels scandal , Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. in August 2019 subpoenaed Mazars for Trump's tax returns.[12] [13] Trump filed suit against the district attorney and Mazars in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York to block the subpoena arguing that a sitting president enjoys "absolute immunity from criminal process of any kind."[13]
Prosecutors countered that Trump had "sweeping immunity" from a criminal probe while he was in office and that Trump was "seeking to invent and enforce a new presidential 'tax return privilege,' on the theory that disclosing information in a tax return will necessarily reveal information that will somehow impede the functioning of a President, sufficiently to meet the test of irreparable harm."[14] [15]
The District Court dismissed the case on the basis of _Younger v. Harris _ (1971), which had stated federal courts should abstain in the matters of tort claims being brought by the person who was prosecuted by those claims. As such, the District Court ordered Trump to comply with the subpoena, pending a ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit .[13] [16]
Second Circuit
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trump_v._Vance&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Second Circuit")
The Second Circuit panel ruled unanimously against Trump in November 2019. The decision stated that the president is not immune from "the enforcement of a state grand jury subpoena directing a third party to produce non-privileged material, even when the subject matter under investigation pertains to the President" and that a state grand jury may issue subpoenas "in aid of its investigation of potential crimes committed by persons within its jurisdiction, even if that investigation may in some way implicate the President."[17] [18]
Supreme Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Trump_v._Vance&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Supreme Court")
Trump petitioned to the U.S. Supreme Court on the Second Circuit's ruling to the New York district attorney subpoena as well as in the separate cases related to the House Committee subpoenas. The Supreme Court agreed to take all three cases in December 2019, consolidating the two House Committee cases into Trump v. Mazars and handling the New York case under Trump v. Vance separately.[19]
Oral arguments were held on May 12, 2020, alongside the Trump v. Mazars arguments, both as part of the set of cases held through teleconference because of the [COVID-19 pandemic](https://e
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- describing the President’s “duties, which range from faithfully executing the laws to commanding the Armed Forces,” as “of unrivaled gravity and breadth”
- “In our judicial system, ‘the public has a right to every man’s evidence.’” (quote attributed to Lord Chancellor Hardwicke)
- prosecutors cannot use subpoenas in “attempt to influence the performance of . . . official duties” that law bars them from controlling
- Rejection of Defendant's contention that \diversion occasioned by a state criminal subpoena imposes an equally intolerable burden on a President's ability to perform his Article II functions.\
- strongly suggesting that courts should quash grand-jury subpoenas with improper purpose
- “‘In our judicial system, the public has a right to every man's evidence.’ Since the earliest days of the Republic, ‘every man’ has included the President of the United States . . . . [b]eginning with Jefferson and carrying on through Clinton . . . .”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: John G. Roberts
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Dixon v. Von BlanckenseeSecond Circuit· 2021-04-12· cited 125×
- Trump v. Mazars USA, LLPSupreme Court· 2020-07-09· cited 58×
- Trump v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2024-07-01· cited 41×
- Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University v. CIAD.C. Circuit· 2021-08-27· cited 34×
- Carroll v. TrumpSecond Circuit· 2023-12-13· cited 28×
- Yelp Inc. v. PaxtonNinth Circuit· 2025-05-15· cited 17×
- Trump v. AndersonSupreme Court· 2024-03-04· cited 12×
- Trump v. VanceSecond Circuit· 2020-10-07· cited 10×
- Donald Trump v. Mazars USA, LLPD.C. Circuit· 2022-07-08· cited 4×
- Jeffrey Hout v. State of Alaska, Office of the Governor, and Governor Mike Dunleavy, in an Official CapacityAlaska Supreme Court· 2023-11-17· cited 2×
- Thompson v. TrumpDistrict of Columbia· 2022-02-18
- United States v. MichelDistrict of Columbia· 2023-03-06
- United States v. TrumpDistrict of Columbia· 2023-12-01
- State of Texas v. DHSFifth Circuit· 2024-11-27
- Validity of Congressional Subpoena That Would Prevent the Secretary of State from Fulfilling the President's Directive to Represent the United States at a Major Diplomatic EventOffice of Legal Counsel· 2024-09-23
- Elizabeth Alexander v. President Donald J. TrumpDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2025-05-28
- CHARETTE, EX PARTE ROBBIE GAIL v. the State of TexasCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2025-08-20
- Moore v. United States En BancDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2025-09-04
- Yanping Chen v. FBID.C. Circuit· 2025-09-30
- In re FirstEnergy Corp.Sixth Circuit· 2025-10-03
Cites
49 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Younger v. HarrisSupreme Court· 1971-02-23· cited 14,568×
- United States v. NixonSupreme Court· 1974-07-24· cited 4,095×
- Clinton v. JonesSupreme Court· 1997-05-27· cited 2,415×
- Dombrowski v. PfisterSupreme Court· 1965-04-26· cited 2,255×
- Branzburg v. HayesSupreme Court· 1972-06-29· cited 2,202×
- Osborn v. Bank of United StatesSupreme Court· 1824-03-19· cited 1,899×
- Cheney v. United States District Court for District of ColumbiaSupreme Court· 2004-06-24· cited 1,878×
- Huffman v. Pursue, Ltd.Supreme Court· 1975-05-12· cited 1,716×
- Hamdi v. RumsfeldSupreme Court· 2004-06-28· cited 1,441×
- United States v. Detroit Timber & Lumber Co.Supreme Court· 1906-02-19· cited 1,300×
- Coy v. IowaSupreme Court· 1988-06-29· cited 1,295×
- Crosby v. National Foreign Trade CouncilSupreme Court· 2000-06-19· cited 1,032×
- Nixon v. FitzgeraldSupreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 972×
- Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc. v. Waterman Steamship Corp.Supreme Court· 1948-04-13· cited 928×
- Myers v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1926-10-25· cited 897×
- Department of Commerce v. New YorkSupreme Court· 2019-06-27· cited 658×
- Dames & Moore v. ReganSupreme Court· 1981-07-02· cited 518×
- United States v. PinkSupreme Court· 1942-02-02· cited 508×
- In re Sealed CaseD.C. Circuit· 1997-06-17· cited 467×
- Environmental Protection Agency v. California Ex Rel. State Water Resources Control BoardSupreme Court· 1976-06-07· cited 449×
Other cases named Trump v. Vance
4 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.