Thompson's Appeal
Citations
- 271 Pa. 225
- 114 A. 774
- 1921 Pa. LEXIS 486
Syllabus
<p>Taxation — Tax settlement — Appeals — Consolidating appeals— Assignment — Findings of reviewing judge — Coal lands — Market value — Foot-acre rule — Presumption from assessment records — Practice, C. P.</p> <p>1. Where, on an appeal from a triennial tax assessment of lands, one of the three judges is designated to find the facts, the findings of such judge is not conclusive upon his associates.</p> <p>2. When the case comes back to the whole court on report or exceptions, it may be treated, in final disposition, unaffected by the findings or opinion of the minority.</p> <p>8. On appeal from final disposition, the appellate court will not reverse except for clear error in .the ultimate determinations.</p> <p>4. On appeal from a tax assessment of coal lands, where there has been no sales of land in the immediate vicinity, a standard, reasonable and fair value, approximating the market value, which in fact would be such, may take its place. The proof must be sufficient to overthrow the prima facie case made out by the presumption from the record of assessments.</p> <p>5. A value fixed on all the essential elements that go to make up its worth, such elements as appear reasonable to fair-minded men, should satisfy the property owner and the county. The court must determine the value from the best evidence available.</p> <p>6. Under the extraordinary conditions of this ease, and because the foot-acre rule could not be applied, — the seams being of uneven and varying thickness, with pockets, — the value of such land may be established by the opinion of mining engineers, who must take into consideration all matters affecting the probable selling price of the land, including the probable quantity of marketable or minable coal in the ground.</p> <p>7. Where, on appeal from tax assessment of coal lands in several townships, there is evidence to justify a statement of proportionate value, and the court below inadvertently fails to allow a proper reduction based thereon, as t
Judges: Frazer, Kephart, Sadler, Schaffer, Simpson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
5 cases in this archive cite this case.
- In Re Appeal of Borough of ChurchillSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1990-05-23· cited 107×
- Miller's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-01-07· cited 39×
- Kemble's EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1924-05-12· cited 35×
- Mathies Coal Co. AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1969-06-27· cited 11×
- Prescott's AppealJefferson County Court of Common Pleas· 1925-11-27
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Philadelphia & Reading Coal & Iron Co. v. Northumberland County CommissionersSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1911-01-03· cited 53×
- State Line & Sullivan R. R.'s TaxationSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1919-04-28· cited 12×
- Lehigh Valley Coal Co. v. Luzerne CountySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1916-07-01· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.