The Granite State
Citations
- 70 U.S. 310
- 18 L. Ed. 179
- 3 Wall. 310
- 1865 U.S. LEXIS 713
Syllabus
<p>1. Where tbe question of fault in a collision lies, on the one hand, between a boat fast at a wharf, out of the track of other vessels, and moored, in all respects of place and signals, or want of them, according to the port regulations of the place, and, on the other, a steamer navigating a channel of sufficient width for her to move and stop at pleasure, the fault, under almost any circumstances, where there is no unusual action of the elements or other superior force driving her to the place-of collision, will be held to be with the steamer.</p> <p>Hence a steamer which, in going in the dark from a broad channel into her dock, runs — though in an effort to avoid other steamers coming out of their docks — against a barge moored at a wharf according to the port regulations, is responsible for the collision. Nor is it an excuse that the barge was without masts, lay low, and owing to her color was not visible in the dark till you were close by her; nor, if the port regulations of the place do not require them from vessels moored at wharves, that she was without both light and watch. *</p> <p>2. The sum which it will take to repair her is not an incorrect rule of damage, in case of injury from collision to an old barge of a peculiar structure and capacities of usefulness, and from these causes not having any established market value in the particular port where she is injured.</p>
Judges: Grier
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
66 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- The\ Virginia Ehrman\ and The\ Agnese\Supreme Court· 1878-01-18· cited 94×
- The President MadisonNinth Circuit· 1937-08-23· cited 79×
- Dahlmer v. Bay State Dredging & Contracting Co.First Circuit· 1928-05-31· cited 53×
- O'Brien Bros. v. the Helen B. MoranSecond Circuit· 1947-03-28· cited 46×
- Hanson K. Dreijer, D/B/A Hanson Dreijer Marine Enterprises v. Girod Motor Company, Inc.Fifth Circuit· 1961-09-15· cited 24×
- Gulf of MexicoSecond Circuit· 1922-03-13· cited 21×
- Pennsylvania Railroad Co. v. the SS BeatriceS.D. New York· 1958-03-25· cited 20×
- City of MaconSecond Circuit· 1903-02-25· cited 12×
- Bisso v. Inland Waterways Corp.E.D. Louisiana· 1953-09-01· cited 11×
- Sewerage and Water Board v. the Joe L. HillE.D. Louisiana· 1954-01-08· cited 10×
- Alaska S. S. Co. v. Inland Navigation Co.Ninth Circuit· 1914-02-02· cited 10×
- The Charles HubbardSixth Circuit· 1916-01-14· cited 10×
- The RotherfieldS.D. Alabama· 1903-06-10· cited 9×
- Galveston Towing Co. v. Cuban S. S. Co.Fifth Circuit· 1912-04-13· cited 9×
- United Fruit Co. v. Mobile Towing & Wrecking Co.S.D. Alabama· 1959-09-30· cited 8×
- The Benjamin A. Van BruntE.D. Pennsylvania· 1925-01-16· cited 8×
- The WaterfordSecond Circuit· 1925-05-04· cited 8×
- The LucilleS.D. Alabama· 1909-04-17· cited 8×
- The AdventuressD. Massachusetts· 1914-04-23· cited 8×
- Ira S. Bushey & Sons, Inc. v. The LehighW.D. New York· 1935-08-15· cited 7×
Other cases named The Granite State
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.