Thayer v. Denver & R. G. R.
Citations
- 25 N.M. 559
- 185 P. 542
Syllabus
<p>SYLLABUS BY THE COURT</p> <p>1. Special findings of a jury will not justify the setting aside of a general verdict unless such findings are in irreconcilable conflict with the general verdict. P. 5 64</p> <p>2. The special interrogatory submitted should call for findings upon the material issues raised by the pleadings, and before such findings will overthrow the general verdict, they must be antagonistic thereto upon the ultimate issue or issues necessarily determined by the general verdict. P. 564</p> <p>3. The answer by the jury to an interrogatory, “We don’t know,” is equivalent to a finding against the party holding the affirmative upon such fact. P. 564</p> <p>4. In an action agaánst a railroad company for injuries alleged to have been incurred by reason of a violation of the federal Safety Appliance Act (U. S. Comp. St. § 8605 et seq.) by the railroad company, the defense of assumption of risk and contributory negligence are eliminated by the federal Employers’ Liability Act (sections 8657 — 8665). P. 565</p> <p>5. Under the federal Safety Appliance Act, an absolute and unqualified duty is imposed upon the carrier to see that its cars are equipped with efficient hand brakes. P. 565</p> <p>6. The' words “efficient,” “inefficient,” and “defective” defined. Held, that the word “defective” is not the antonym of “efficient,” and, where the federal Safety Appliance Act requires all cars to be equipped with efficient hand brakes, a finding by the jury, in answer to a special interrogatory, that the hand brake rigging on the car in question was not in any manner defective, is not equivalent to a finding that the car was equipped with an efficient han.d brake. P. 566</p> <p>7. ' A finding that a hand brake upon a railroad car was not defective did not override a general verdict which was necessarily based upon a finding that the hand brake was inefficient. P. 5 66</p>
Judges: Parker, Raynolds, Roberts
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
7 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Chandler v. BattenfieldNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1951-07-13· cited 30×
- Bass v. DehnerTenth Circuit· 1939-02-14· cited 24×
- Bree v. JalbertNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1965-04-27· cited 14×
- Bryant v. HB Lynn Drilling CorporationNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1959-01-08· cited 7×
- Rheinboldt v. FustonNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1929-02-23· cited 6×
- Thayer v. Denver & R. G. R.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1922-02-22· cited 2×
- Delaney v. Tampa Northern R.S.D. Florida· 1924-12-17
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Texas & Pacific Railway Co. v. RigsbySupreme Court· 1916-04-17· cited 633×
- St. Louis, Iron Mountain & Southern Railway Co. v. TaylorSupreme Court· 1908-05-18· cited 351×
- Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railway Co. v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1911-05-15· cited 206×
- San Antonio & Aransas Pass Railway Co. v. WagnerSupreme Court· 1916-06-05· cited 151×
- Spokane & Inland Empire Railroad v. CampbellSupreme Court· 1916-06-12· cited 142×
- Delk v. St. Louis & San Francisco RailroadSupreme Court· 1911-05-15· cited 132×
- Union Pacific Railroad v. HuxollSupreme Court· 1918-01-21· cited 38×
- Upton v. Santa Rita Mining Co.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1907-02-27· cited 21×
- Gallegos v. SandovalNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1909-08-31· cited 11×
- Hilligoss v. Missouri, Kansas & Texas Railway Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1911-03-11· cited 5×
- Leyba v. Albuquerque & Cerrillos Coal Co.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1919-06-28· cited 4×
- Hayden v. Missouri, Kansas & Texas Railway Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1911-03-11· cited 3×
Other cases named Thayer v. Denver & R. G. R.
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.