Territory v. Alcantara
Citations
- 24 Haw. 197
- 1918 Haw. LEXIS 61
Syllabus
<p>Appear and Error — exceptions.</p> <p>A general exception to the entire charge of the court given to the jury does not bring to the attention of this court any specific question of law presented to the lower court and is too general to he considered in the appellate court.</p> <p>Homicide — intent.</p> <p>In determining the criminality of the act of killing it is immaterial whether the intent was to kill the person killed, or whether the death of such person was the accidental or otherwise unintentional result of the intent to kill someone else.</p> <p>Same — manslaughter—instructions.</p> <p>On the trial of a person accused of committing the crime of murder, if there be no evidence upon which the jury can properly find the defendant guilty of an offense of a lesser degree than the one charged it is not error to instruct the jury that it cannot return a verdict of guilty of manslaughter or of any offense less than the one charged.</p> <p>Same — same—same.</p> <p>But in a prosecution for murder, where there is some substantial evidence, however weak and inconclusive it may appear to the trial court, that would tend to mitigate the homicide to manslaughter, it is error for the court to refuse to .instruct the jury concerning manslaughter. Held, in this case, that such instruction should have been given.</p>
Judges: Coke, Kemp, Quarles
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
18 cases in this archive cite this case.
- State v. SantiagoHawaii Supreme Court· 1971-12-29· cited 256×
- State v. O'DANIELHawaii Supreme Court· 1980-09-25· cited 71×
- State v. FosterHawaii Supreme Court· 1960-08-16· cited 35×
- State v. MoellerHawaii Supreme Court· 1967-10-31· cited 32×
- State v. StengerHawaii Supreme Court· 2010-03-04· cited 28×
- State v. HornHawaii Supreme Court· 1977-08-05· cited 28×
- State v. ChangHawaii Supreme Court· 1962-07-20· cited 26×
- State v. WarnerHawaii Supreme Court· 1977-12-23· cited 21×
- State v. RiveiraHawaii Supreme Court· 1978-04-25· cited 19×
- State v. TravisHawaii Supreme Court· 1962-01-18· cited 19×
- State v. AuldHawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals· 2007-04-17· cited 16×
- State v. Taylor.Hawaii Supreme Court· 2013-08-02· cited 15×
- State v. IrvinHawaii Supreme Court· 1971-08-27· cited 15×
- State v. LiraHawaii Supreme Court· 1988-07-14· cited 14×
- Territory v. KaehaHawaii Supreme Court· 1918-10-17· cited 6×
- State v. UneaHawaii Supreme Court· 1979-03-02· cited 5×
- Territory v. BarquesHawaii Supreme Court· 1920-06-08· cited 2×
- Guieb v. Guieb. ICA mem. op., filed 08/07/2024 [ada], 154 Haw. 415. Application for Writ of Certiorari, filed 11/06/2024. S.Ct. Order Accepting Application for Writ of Certiorari, filed 12/19/2024 [ada].Hawaii Supreme Court· 2025-07-01
Cites
12 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Hopt v. People of Territory of UtahSupreme Court· 1884-03-03· cited 1,005×
- Sparf v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1895-01-21· cited 757×
- Ringer v. StateSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1905-02-18· cited 39×
- Brown v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1895-06-03· cited 27×
- State v. BuffingtonSupreme Court of Kansas· 1903-04-11· cited 24×
- De Fraga v. Portuguese Mutual Benefit SocietyHawaii Supreme Court· 1895-10-18· cited 19×
- Territory of Hawaii ex rel. Andrews v. PuahiHawaii Supreme Court· 1908-03-26· cited 16×
- Ripley & Davis v. Kapiolani Estate, Ltd.Hawaii Supreme Court· 1915-03-24· cited 15×
- Republic of Hawaii v. KapeaHawaii Supreme Court· 1898-02-03· cited 9×
- Wirt v. PhilipsHawaii Supreme Court· 1852-04-03· cited 6×
- Kulike v. FernHawaii Supreme Court· 1909-01-07· cited 5×
- Kennedy v. SniffenHawaii Supreme Court· 1916-01-15· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.