Skip to main content

Swasey v. Adair

Citations

  • 88 Cal. 179
  • 25 P. 1119
  • 1891 Cal. LEXIS 669

Syllabus

<p>Trial — Legal Defense — Trial by Jury. —The court does not acquire the right to pass upon a legal defense without a jury trial by virtue of being first called upon to dispose of an equitable defense; and if the trial of the equitable defense does not obviate the necessity of a trial of the issues of law, they must be tried in the same manner as if no equitable defense had been interposed.</p> <p>Ed. — Equitable Defense.— How Constituted—Equitable Right of Action. — It is not every defense of an equitable nature which may be interposed to an action at law which must be tried by the court before proceeding to a trial of the issues of law, but only such a defense as is properly an equitable right of action, existing in behalf of the defendant which he might have asserted in an independent suit brought by him against the plaintiff for the purpose of enforcing such right, but which he can rely upon as a defense in an action involving the same subject-matter brought against him by the plaintiff.</p> <p>Id. — Pleading of Equitable Defense. — The party relying upon such equitable defense must plead it with the same fullness and particularity as is required in eases involving like subjects of inquiry in suits in equity; and his answer, being in .the nature of a bill in equity, must contain all the essen tial averments of such a bilL Id.—Defense in Replevin — Claim of Title —Legal Issue.—In an action for the recovery of personal property, a claim in the answer that the defendant is the owner of the property is merely a mode of denying the plaintiff’s title, and presents only a legal issue as to the title of the property.</p> <p>Id.—Separate Answer — Conspiracy and Deceit — Damages — Equitable Defense. — A second count of the answer, setting forth separately an alleged conspiracy and deceit practiced upon the defendant by the plaintiff and others in relation to the property in controversy, and claiming damages therefor, presents no equitable defense which the court is justi

Judges: Harrison

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

18 cases in this archive cite this case.

Cites

7 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

Other cases named Swasey v. Adair

1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.