Tenth Circuit· 11/27/2001
Stuart v. Colorado Interstate Gas Co.
Citations
- 271 F.3d 1221
- 2001 U.S. App. LEXIS 25246
- 2001 WL 1497728
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that there are cases where the court will not take jurisdiction unless the plaintiff has asserted a claim cognizable in state courts
- explaining that under a 12(b)(1) facial attack “the district court must accept the complaint allegations as true”
- explaining that under a 12(b)(1) “facial attack, the district court must accept the complaint allegations as true”
- explaining that the defendant “chose the second form of attack” by going “beyond allegations contained in the complaint and challeng[ing] the facts upon which subject matter jurisdiction is based”
- recognizing under a 12(b)(1) factual challenge to subject matter jurisdiction, “a court has wide discretion to allow affidavits, other documents, and a limited evidentiary hearing to resolve disputed jurisdictional facts” (internal quotation marks and citation omitted)
- noting that in making an Erie guess, the court is “free to consider all resources available, including decisions of [the state’s] courts, other state courts and federal courts, in addition to the general weight and trend of authority”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Kelly, McKay, Brown
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
51 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Montoya v. ChaoTenth Circuit· 2002-07-11· cited 585×
- Radil v. Sanborn Western Camps, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2004-09-22· cited 325×
- Maestas v. State of ColoradoTenth Circuit· 2003-11-26· cited 178×
- Muscogee (Creek) Nation v. Oklahoma Tax CommissionTenth Circuit· 2010-07-09· cited 165×
- Johnson v. RiddleTenth Circuit· 2002-09-05· cited 153×
- County of Santa Fe v. Public Service Co.Tenth Circuit· 2002-11-26· cited 139×
- McBride v. Citgo Petroleum Corp.Tenth Circuit· 2002-02-21· cited 120×
- Baker v. USD 229 Blue ValleyTenth Circuit· 2020-11-03· cited 101×
- Northern Natural Gas Co. v. Nash Oil & Gas, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2008-05-19· cited 96×
- Ingram v. FaruqueTenth Circuit· 2013-09-06· cited 69×
- Pehle v. Farm Bureau Life InsuranceTenth Circuit· 2005-02-09· cited 46×
- Anderson v. Commerce Construction Services, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2008-07-02· cited 36×
- CONSUMER DATA INDUSTRY ASS'N v. KingTenth Circuit· 2012-05-07· cited 34×
- Hennessey v. University of Kansas Hospital AuthorityTenth Circuit· 2022-11-09· cited 34×
- Lanham v. Nationstar Mortgage, LLCS.D. West Virginia· 2016-03-11· cited 25×
- Cincinnati Indemnity Co. v. a & K Construction Co.Eighth Circuit· 2008-09-15· cited 23×
- Pouliot v. Paul Arpin Van Lines, Inc.D. Connecticut· 2003-11-26· cited 13×
- Odom v. Penske Truck Leasing Co., L.P.Tenth Circuit· 2018-06-19· cited 13×
- Murphy v. GormanD. New Mexico· 2010-06-09· cited 11×
- Rupp v. Transcontinental InsuranceD. Utah· 2008-11-17· cited 9×
Cites
28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Klaxon Co. v. Stentor Electric Manufacturing Co.Supreme Court· 1941-06-02· cited 8,668×
- Saint Paul Mercury Indemnity Co. v. Red Cab Co.Supreme Court· 1938-02-28· cited 3,971×
- David Holt, as Personal Representative of the Estates of James W. Holt and Joan Holt, Deceased v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 1995-01-30· cited 945×
- Lehman Brothers v. ScheinSupreme Court· 1974-04-29· cited 767×
- Angel v. BullingtonSupreme Court· 1947-02-17· cited 644×
- Allstate Insurance v. HagueSupreme Court· 1981-03-02· cited 549×
- Wilson v. FaullSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1958-05-19· cited 73×
- Crider v. Zurich InsuranceSupreme Court· 1965-03-01· cited 50×
- Wood v. Eli Lilly & Co.Tenth Circuit· 1994-10-11· cited 49×
- Simaitis v. FloodSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1980-08-05· cited 41×
- Studebaker Bros. v. MauWyoming Supreme Court· 1905-08-28· cited 41×
- Jonathan Woodner Co. v. MatherD.C. Circuit· 1954-03-19· cited 37×
- Wessel v. Mapco, Inc.Wyoming Supreme Court· 1988-03-30· cited 36×
- Proctor & Schwartz, Inc. And Scm Corporation v. C. F. RollinsFourth Circuit· 1980-11-13· cited 34×
- Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation v. Bernard SchuchmannFirst Circuit· 2000-12-19· cited 33×
- Enfield Ex Rel. Enfield v. A.B. Chance Co.Tenth Circuit· 2000-10-17· cited 30×
- Eger v. E.I. Du Pont DeNemours Co.Supreme Court of New Jersey· 1988-04-20· cited 22×
- Mills v. ReynoldsWyoming Supreme Court· 1991-05-06· cited 21×
- Tucci v. Club Mediterranee, SACalifornia Court of Appeal· 2001-05-18· cited 19×
- Garcia v. American Airlines, Inc.First Circuit· 1993-12-29· cited 12×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.