Seventh Circuit· 5/30/1996
Steven Steele v. Han Chul Choi
Citations
- 82 F.3d 175
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- explaining that constitutional claim cannot be established simply by offering evidence that another medical professional would have chosen a different course of treatment
- evidence that some medical professionals would have chosen a different course of treatment is insufficient to make out a constitutional claim
- courts must “distinguish between deliberate indifference to serious medical needs of prisoners, on the one hand, and negligen[ce] in diagnosing or treating medical condi- tion, on the other,” and “only the former” violates the Eighth Amendment (citations omitted)
- “If the symptoms plainly called for a particular medical treatment—the leg is broken, so it must be set; the person is not breathing, so CPR must be administered—a doctor’s deliberate decision not to furnish the treatment might be actionable under § 1983.”
- “If the symptoms plainly called for a particular medical treatment—the leg is broken, so it must be set; the person is not breathing, so CPR must be administered—a doctor’s deliberate decision not to furnish the treatment might be actionable under § 1983.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Kanne, Wood, Skinner
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
44 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Tyrone Petties v. Imhotep CarterSeventh Circuit· 2016-08-25· cited 1,624×
- Jackie Vance v. Howard Peters, Iii, Director, Jane E. Higgins, Warden, and James Roy, Correctional OfficerSeventh Circuit· 1996-12-18· cited 939×
- Gutierrez v. PetersSeventh Circuit· 1997-04-23· cited 877×
- Van Dyke Johnson v. Stephen Doughty, Doctor, John Cearlock, Don HinderliterSeventh Circuit· 2006-01-17· cited 821×
- Unnamed caseThird Circuit· 2001-06-11· cited 792×
- Gayton v. McCoySeventh Circuit· 2010-01-28· cited 786×
- Barbara Ann Collignon and Marc Collignon, of the Estate of Jonathan Collignon v. Milwaukee County, Grace Downing, Joseph LofySeventh Circuit· 1999-01-12· cited 375×
- John Walker v. Dr. Ivy Benjamin, Dr. Adrian Feinerman, Dr. Ansar Ansari, Dr. Virgilio Pilapil, Pamela Dunbar and Vickie RowlandSeventh Circuit· 2002-06-18· cited 302×
- Easter v. PowellFifth Circuit· 2006-10-10· cited 297×
- Xing Qian v. James R. Kautz, as the Chief of Police of the Long Beach Police DepartmentSeventh Circuit· 1999-03-16· cited 174×
- Estate of Cole ex rel. Pardue v. FrommSeventh Circuit· 1996-08-12· cited 155×
- Clara Walker v. Howard Peters, Salvador Godinez, Richard GramleySeventh Circuit· 2000-11-30· cited 140×
- Unnamed caseSeventh Circuit· 2000-06-13· cited 97×
- Clifford Jones v. Randall SimekSeventh Circuit· 1999-09-20· cited 84×
- Richard Foelker v. Outagamie CountySeventh Circuit· 2005-01-07· cited 82×
- Aaron Murphy v. Wexford Health Sources, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2020-06-18· cited 37×
- Ortiz v. WebsterSeventh Circuit· 2011-08-24· cited 31×
- ESTATE OFSeventh Circuit· 1996-08-12· cited 30×
- Edward Pavlick v. Jimmy MifflinSeventh Circuit· 1996-07-18· cited 28×
- Douglas v. DeBruynS.D. Indiana· 1996-07-10· cited 19×
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Farmer v. BrennanSupreme Court· 1994-06-06· cited 28,443×
- Estelle v. GambleSupreme Court· 1976-11-30· cited 28,035×
- Wilson v. SeiterSupreme Court· 1991-06-17· cited 6,530×
- W. Foster Sellers v. Gary L. Henman, L. Knowles, D. FeatherstonSeventh Circuit· 1994-11-18· cited 105×
- Derrick Williams v. Michael O'leary, Clyde E. Nash, Leroy BanksSeventh Circuit· 1995-05-25· cited 55×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.