Supreme Court of Vermont· 5/3/1991
State v. Wetherbee
Citations
- 594 A.2d 390
- 156 Vt. 425
- 1991 Vt. LEXIS 101
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting that, when an expert comments directly on witness credibility, it invades the province of the jury to determine the credibility of witnesses and creates a risk that the expert will be seen as a “truth detector”
- explaining that hearing the testimony of a psychological expert, who could be perceived as a “truth detector,” posed greater danger of prejudice to the jury than hearing testimony of a medical doctor focused primarily on physical treatment
- noting that, when an expert comments directly on witness credibility, it invades the province of the jury to determine the credibility of witnesses and creates a risk that the expert will be seen as a “truth detector”
- comments of expert who has examined the victim are taken in an entirely different light by the jury
- allowance of an expert’s testimony related to victim’s credibility is especially prejudicial because “the average juror believes that psychologists are specially trained to ferret out truth”
- mental health professional who has examined the victim and then testifies as the State’s expert at trial may be perceived by jury as vouching for victim’s credibility
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Allen, Dooley, Morse, Peck, Cashman
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
11 cases in this archive cite this case.
- State v. GrenierSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2001-09-04· cited 52×
- State v. SimsSupreme Court of Vermont· 1991-11-08· cited 37×
- State v. WeeksSupreme Court of Vermont· 1993-06-18· cited 31×
- State v. LyndsSupreme Court of Vermont· 1991-10-25· cited 28×
- State v. WiggSupreme Court of Vermont· 2005-07-29· cited 24×
- State v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Vermont· 1992-04-17· cited 23×
- Soutiere v. SoutiereSupreme Court of Vermont· 1995-02-17· cited 15×
- State v. LaPradeSupreme Court of Vermont· 2008-06-13· cited 13×
- Siegel v. MischSupreme Court of Vermont· 2007-10-11· cited 12×
- State v. BabsonSupreme Court of Vermont· 2006-08-31· cited 7×
- State v. LeggettSupreme Court of Vermont· 1995-06-28· cited 4×
Cites
11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- State v. SaldanaSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1982-08-31· cited 204×
- State v. CatsamSupreme Court of Vermont· 1987-08-14· cited 108×
- State v. BubarSupreme Court of Vermont· 1985-12-06· cited 73×
- State v. GallagherSupreme Court of Vermont· 1988-08-26· cited 50×
- Woodmansee v. StonemanSupreme Court of Vermont· 1975-08-21· cited 40×
- State v. RossSupreme Court of Vermont· 1989-09-08· cited 40×
- State v. GokeySupreme Court of Vermont· 1990-03-16· cited 39×
- State v. FuentesSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1981-08-03· cited 24×
- State v. DunbarSupreme Court of Vermont· 1989-08-25· cited 24×
- State v. DerouchieSupreme Court of Vermont· 1989-10-20· cited 23×
- State v. JarvisSupreme Court of Vermont· 1984-08-10· cited 8×
Other cases named State v. Wetherbee
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.