State v. Tiedjen
Citations
- 2019 Ohio 2430
Syllabus
Motion for leave motion for new trial newly discovered evidence missing evidence App.R. 9 sua sponte Brady violation expert witness testimony res judicata. Denial of defendant's motion for leave to file motion for new trial reversed. Defendant filed a motion based on newly discovered photographs that allegedly show that the police manipulated crime-scene photographs from the 1989 murder and that the police, the prosecutor, or both withheld it from discovery. Court properly found that the evidence was newly discovered, but erred by failing to find that defendant was unavoidably prevented from discovering the photographs. Court also abused its discretion by excluding expert testimony regarding whether the photographs were exculpatory and material. However, the parties concede that the newly discovered photographs are missing from the appellate record. Compliance with App.R. 9 is impossible without the missing photographs or copies of the photographs. Without the missing evidence, this court cannot conduct a meaningful appellate review of whether defendant should receive a new trial based on newly discovered evidence. Case remanded under State v. Jones, 71 Ohio St.3d 293, 643 N.E.2d 547 (1994), to determine whether defendant is substantially responsible for the missing evidence.
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- granting a new trial when the transcript was unavailable through no fault of the parties
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Blackmon
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
4 cases in this archive cite this case.
Cites
21 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Brady v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1963-05-13· cited 33,902×
- United States v. BagleySupreme Court· 1985-07-02· cited 8,539×
- Knapp v. Edwards LaboratoriesOhio Supreme Court· 1980-02-13· cited 2,064×
- State v. SageOhio Supreme Court· 1987-07-08· cited 1,978×
- State v. SteffenOhio Supreme Court· 1994-09-28· cited 454×
- State v. PowellOhio Supreme Court· 2012-06-13· cited 423×
- State v. JohnstonOhio Supreme Court· 1988-10-05· cited 376×
- State v. SkatzesOhio Supreme Court· 2004-12-08· cited 294×
- State v. KossOhio Supreme Court· 1990-03-07· cited 220×
- State v. Tate (Slip Opinion)Ohio Supreme Court· 2014-09-04· cited 124×
- In re Adoption of GreerOhio Supreme Court· 1994-09-21· cited 89×
- State v. DavisOhio Supreme Court· 2011-10-04· cited 81×
- State v. HartmanOhio Court of Appeals· 2016-05-06· cited 57×
- State v. JonesOhio Supreme Court· 1994-12-23· cited 30×
- State v. GloverOhio Court of Appeals· 2016-05-05· cited 21×
- State v. HaleOhio Court of Appeals· 2019-05-16· cited 19×
- In re HolmesOhio Supreme Court· 2004-12-30· cited 17×
- State v. GavenOhio Court of Appeals· 2017-06-27· cited 11×
- State v. ReidOhio Court of Appeals· 2012-04-13· cited 10×
- State v. BryanOhio Court of Appeals· 2018-03-29· cited 7×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.