West Virginia Supreme Court· 7/19/1995
State v. Osakalumi
Citations
- 461 S.E.2d 504
- 194 W. Va. 758
- 1995 W. Va. LEXIS 163
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding as a matter of state constitutional law that \fundamental fairness requires [the court] to evaluate the State's failure to preserve potentially exculpatory evidence in the context of the entire record\
- examining criminal defendant’s right to fair trial in light of negligent failure to preserve evidence
- reversing a first degree murder conviction because the state destroyed potentially useful defense evidence
- “When the State had or should have had evidence requested by a criminal defendant but the evidence no longer exists when the defendant seeks its production, a trial court must determine (1
- “we have previously set our state constitutional protections, in some instances, at a higher level than that accorded by the federal constitution[.]”
- even though police acted negligently in disposing of a couch [with a bullet hole] that “was so obviously a part of a pending police investigation,” court could not say their actions were motivated by bad faith
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: McHugh, Brotherton, Recht, Fox, Miller
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
51 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Illinois v. FisherSupreme Court· 2004-02-23· cited 372×
- State v. FergusonTennessee Supreme Court· 1999-09-20· cited 296×
- State v. MillerWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1996-06-14· cited 224×
- Ex Parte NapperCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2010-09-29· cited 207×
- State v. SalmonsWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1998-11-04· cited 96×
- Pena v. StateTex. App. Ct., 10th Dist. (Waco)· 2007-05-02· cited 95×
- State v. TiedemannUtah Supreme Court· 2007-06-29· cited 93×
- State v. YoungbloodWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2007-06-27· cited 86×
- Pena v. StateTex. App. Ct., 10th Dist. (Waco)· 2005-04-27· cited 63×
- State v. GrimesWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2009-11-16· cited 61×
- Patterson v. StateCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1999-12-09· cited 60×
- State v. PaynterWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1999-12-15· cited 53×
- State v. DennisWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2004-12-01· cited 44×
- State v. MorrisWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2010-11-19· cited 24×
- State v. DeJesusUtah Supreme Court· 2017-04-21· cited 23×
- Wampler Foods, Inc. v. Workers' Compensation DivisionWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2004-08-24· cited 21×
- State of West Virginia v. Ronald C. DavisWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2013-11-21· cited 17×
- People v. VelascoCalifornia Court of Appeal· 2011-04-29· cited 15×
- State v. YoungbloodWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2005-07-12· cited 12×
- State v. LeonardWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2005-06-22· cited 12×
Cites
38 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Brady v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1963-05-13· cited 33,902×
- United States v. AgursSupreme Court· 1976-06-24· cited 6,537×
- Davis v. AlaskaSupreme Court· 1974-02-27· cited 5,953×
- California v. TrombettaSupreme Court· 1984-06-11· cited 3,405×
- Arizona v. YoungbloodSupreme Court· 1989-01-23· cited 3,366×
- United States v. Valenzuela-BernalSupreme Court· 1982-07-02· cited 1,404×
- Lisenba v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1942-02-02· cited 1,400×
- State v. MillerWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1995-05-18· cited 981×
- Killian v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1962-01-22· cited 267×
- Pauley v. KellyWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1979-02-20· cited 248×
- State v. HatfieldWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1982-01-26· cited 169×
- Bailey v. StateSupreme Court of Delaware· 1987-03-03· cited 118×
- State v. EnglandWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1988-09-16· cited 116×
- Deberry v. StateSupreme Court of Delaware· 1983-01-27· cited 112×
- State v. DelisleSupreme Court of Vermont· 1994-07-01· cited 102×
- State v. FortnerWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1989-12-14· cited 92×
- Hammond v. StateSupreme Court of Delaware· 1989-12-28· cited 91×
- Thorne v. Department of Public SafetyAlaska Supreme Court· 1989-05-26· cited 90×
- State v. NeumanWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1988-07-01· cited 85×
- State v. MatafeoHawaii Supreme Court· 1990-02-20· cited 81×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.