State v. McNeil

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• finding that missing evidence was not constitutionally material because, inter alia, the defendant could cross examine responding officers and victim regarding events allegedly recorded on missing DVD
• holding no due process violation resulted from the State's failure to preserve the master DVD of the traffic stop because \there [was] no evidence that the master DVD was destroyed out of an interested or sinister motive or through a conscious doing of wrong\
• holding no due process violation resulted from the State’s failure to preserve the master DVD of the traffic stop because “there [was] no evidence that the master DVD was destroyed out of an interested or sinister motive or through a conscious doing of wrong”
• reversing trial court’s dismissal of charges for failure to preserve exculpatory evidence because nothing suggested that DVD of officer’s pursuit of vehicle in which defendant was a passenger had apparent exculpatory value
• reversing trial court’s dismissal of charges for failure to preserve exculpatory evidence because defendant did not show evidence was destroyed by police out of an interested or sinister motive or through a conscious doing of wrong

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

4 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Hickman v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2011-08-30· cited 13×
• State v. Kenneth Nixon
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2022-06-30
• Ariana Murphy v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2024-12-27
• Gabriel O. Ceballos v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2018-05-14

Cites

18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• United States v. Agurs
  Supreme Court· 1976-06-24· cited 6,537×
• California v. Trombetta
  Supreme Court· 1984-06-11· cited 3,405×
• Arizona v. Youngblood
  Supreme Court· 1989-01-23· cited 3,366×
• Illinois v. Fisher
  Supreme Court· 2004-02-23· cited 372×
• Davis v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2009-04-28· cited 59×
• Krause v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2010-03-22· cited 51×
• Walker v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 1994-11-28· cited 48×
• Brannan v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2002-03-25· cited 47×
• Fincher v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2003-02-24· cited 47×
• Milton v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 1998-05-27· cited 36×
• State v. Blackwell
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2000-07-14· cited 27×
• Lynott v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 1991-02-06· cited 22×
• Swanson v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2001-03-12· cited 16×
• State v. Miller
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2010-09-20· cited 14×
• Brantley v. State
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 1991-04-09· cited 11×
• State v. Brawner
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2009-05-13· cited 10×
• Ballard v. State
  Supreme Court of Georgia· 2009-02-09· cited 8×
• State v. Miller
  Court of Appeals of Georgia· 2009-06-29· cited 7×