Skip to main content
Ohio Supreme Court· 12/6/1920

State v. Hauser

Citations

  • 101 Ohio St. (N.S.) 404

Syllabus

<p>Criminal law — Evidence — Preponderance to establish insanity — Charge to jury — Correct and incorrect instruction given — No presumption jury followed correct rule, when.</p> <p>1. In the trial of a criminal case where the defense of insanity is made, a charge of the court which places upon the accused in the making of such defense a greater burden than the furnishing of a preponderance of evidence is erroneous. (Bond v. State, 23 Ohio St., 349; Bergin v. State, 31 Ohio St., Ill; Kelch v. State, 55 Ohio St., 146; State v. Austin, 71 Ohio St., 317, in this respect approved and followed.)</p> <p>2. Where two rules as to the quantum of evidence required of the accused are given to the jury, the one correct and the other erroneous, the court will not presume that the jury followed the correct rule to the exclusion of the incorrect rule.</p> <p>3. In a criminal prosecution wherein the defense of insanity is interposed by defendant, a charge to the jury that “proof in support of insanity must be affirmatively established by positive or circumstantial evidence, which must satisfy you that he was not sane,” is erroneous; and such instruction is not qualified or modified by a further charge that “Before you can find * * * [defendant] was insane * * * you must be satisfied by a preponderance or greater weight of the evidence * * Such latter charge presents to the jury an independent or different rule as to the quantum of evidence necessary to establish such defense, and does not cure the erroneous charge theretofore given.</p>

Judges: Avery, Johnson, Jones, Matthias, Nichols, Robinson, Wanamaker

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.