State v. Francisco Pacheco
Citations
- 161 A.3d 1166
- 2017 WL 2622780
- 2017 R.I. LEXIS 87
Syllabus
The defendant, Francisco Pacheco (Pacheco or defendant), appealed from a judgment of conviction in the Superior Court the basis of this appeal was that the doctrine of collateral estoppel should have barred the state from prosecuting a chemical breath test refusal under G.L. 1956 § 31-27-2.1. Specifically, the defendant contended that the ultimate issues of fact relevant to the chemical refusal were already decided in the Traffic Tribunal in connection with a preliminary refusal infraction. The Supreme Court held that the doctrine of collateral estoppel did not apply under the circumstances because the two refusals did not involve identical issues. The Court also determined that the preliminary refusal was not \actually litigated\ in the Traffic Tribunal because it was dismissed for a lack of evidentiary foundation. Furthermore, the Supreme Court acknowledged the differences between a civil infraction in the Traffic Tribunal and a criminal charge in Superior Court, but the Court did not base its decision upon these differences.
Judges: Suttell, Goldberg, Flaherty, Robinson, Indeglia
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
4 cases in this archive cite this case.
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Ashe v. SwensonSupreme Court· 1970-04-20· cited 4,277×
- Lucido v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1990-09-06· cited 733×
- Gilberg v. BarbieriNew York Court of Appeals· 1981-06-16· cited 434×
- Davis v. Dennis B.California Supreme Court· 1976-12-28· cited 104×
- Foster-Glocester Regional School Committee v. Board of ReviewSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2004-07-16· cited 78×
- State v. ChaseSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1991-03-14· cited 72×
- Casco Indemnity Co. v. O'ConnorSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2000-07-06· cited 43×
- State v. DiStefanoSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2000-12-20· cited 41×
- Briggeman v. AlbertCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1991-02-26· cited 34×
- State v. OsterSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2007-05-22· cited 29×
- State v. GautierSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2005-04-12· cited 29×
- State v. GodetteSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2000-05-15· cited 28×
- State v. WalkerCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 1989-01-26· cited 25×
- State v. SnellSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-02-27· cited 24×
- State v. ZnoskoSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2000-08-02· cited 21×
- State v. HieSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1996-01-10· cited 21×
- State v. WernerSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2005-01-12· cited 14×
- State v. JenkinsSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1996-04-17· cited 12×
- State v. RodriguezSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2007-03-08· cited 9×
- Kenlin Properties, LLC v. City of East ProvidenceSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2016-06-23· cited 5×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.