State v. Downing
Citations
- 24 Wash. 340
- 64 P. 550
- 1901 Wash. LEXIS 539
Syllabus
<p>HOMICIDE —■ IDENTIFICATION OF BODY-CONCLUSIVENESS OF JURY’S FINDING.</p> <p>In a prosecution for murder, in which the identity of the dead body is a question in issue, for the reason that the flesh of its face had been eaten away beyond recognition, the' verdict of the jury establishing identity of the body with that of the alleged murdered man is conclusive on the appellate court, when it appears that the deceased was last seen alive near the point where the body was discovered, that the body , corresponded with that of deceased in stature, size and hair, that the clothing on it was similar to that worn by deceased when last seen alive, and that a button on the shirt was identified by a witness as having been given by him to deceased some months before.</p> <p>SAME-CIRCUMSTANTIAL EVIDENCE-SUFFICIENCY.</p> <p>In a prosecution for murder, the jury is not warranted in finding defendant guilty, when the evidence shows that deceased was last seen alive rowing his boat in the direction of defendant’s shack, that ten days later his overturned boat was found adrift and two days subsequently his body was found partially embedded in the sand on the beach, about a mile and a half from defendant’s shack; that by reason of decomposition and the feeding of crabs and gulls on the exposed portions of the face and neck it was difficult to tell whether violence had been used against deceased, but some of the persons witnessing the body were under the impression that the throat had been cut; that the defendant and deceased had theretofore had some slight quarrel over trivial matters, but there was no proof of bad blood between them; and there were no indications of the use of violence in or about the shack or the deceased’s boat, nor was there any evidence of blood upon the clothing or boat of deceased, or upon the clothing or person of defendant nor upon the contents of his shack.</p>
Judges: Fullerton
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
2 cases in this archive cite this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.