State v. Carlton Vose
Syllabus
The defendant, Carlton Vose, appealed from his conviction in Superior Court on six counts of neglecting an adult with severe impairments, in violation of G.L. 1956 § 11-5-12. On appeal, the defendant raised several issues: (1) whether § 11 5 12 is ambiguous as written (2) whether medical testimony is necessary to establish \severe impairment\ under § 11-5-12 (3) whether the trial justice misapplied the law when he denied the motion for a new trial and (4) whether the state violated Rule 16 of the Superior Court Rules of Criminal Procedure by failing to provide a witness list before the first day of trial, and then by calling less than half of the witnesses who were identified.<br> <br>The Supreme Court concluded that the language of § 11-5-12 was clear and unambiguous and not susceptible to more than one meaning, and that defendant had notice of the conduct proscribed by the statute. Additionally, the Court held that §11-5-12 does not require expert testimony to establish \severe impairment\ as this determination was not beyond the grasp of the \average layman.\ State v. Sheridan, 252 A.3d 1236, 1246 (R.I. 2021).<br><br>Regarding the defendant's contention that the trial justice misapplied the law when he denied the motion for a new trial, the Supreme Court concluded that the trial justice thoroughly performed the required three-step process when making this determination, and declined to disturb his ruling. Lastly, the Court declined to address the defendant's assertion that the state violated Rule 16 as this issue was not properly preserved for review.<br><br>Accordingly, the Supreme Court affirmed the judgment of the Superior Court. <br>
Cites
22 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. OteroSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2002-01-24· cited 54×
- State v. Adrian HazardSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2013-06-19· cited 47×
- Long v. Dell, Inc.Supreme Court of Rhode Island· 2009-12-14· cited 42×
- State v. FonsecaSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1996-02-08· cited 34×
- State v. RussellSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-01-30· cited 28×
- State v. Paul FleckSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2014-01-15· cited 23×
- State v. GouletSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2011-06-16· cited 22×
- State v. BrownSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1963-12-18· cited 21×
- In Re William, Susan, and JosephSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1982-08-06· cited 20×
- State v. SmithSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1995-07-24· cited 19×
- State v. AlbaneseSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2009-05-29· cited 17×
- State Ex Rel. Town of Westerly v. BradleySupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2005-06-21· cited 15×
- State v. MondesirSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-02-20· cited 15×
- State v. CarterSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2003-07-01· cited 14×
- State v. StierhoffSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2005-04-19· cited 14×
- State v. Anthony MooreSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2017-02-27· cited 12×
- State v. SahadySupreme Court of Rhode Island· 1997-06-05· cited 11×
- State v. AlstonSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2012-06-22· cited 11×
- State v. GardinerSupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2006-04-25· cited 9×
- State v. FarleySupreme Court of Rhode Island· 2009-01-14· cited 6×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.