State v. Bundy
Citations
- 24 S.C. 439
- 1886 S.C. LEXIS 59
Syllabus
<p>1. In order to make out the defence of insanity to the charge of murder, there must be sufficient proof to overcome by the preponderance of evidence, the presumption of sanity and any other proof by the State upon this issue, so as to show a want of sanity with reasonable certainty ; this degree of evidence on the part of the defendant satisfies the requirement that the State must establish every element of the crime charged “beyond a reasonable doubt.”</p> <p>2. The evidence in this case does not prove that the defendant was in a state of temporary intoxication when he committed the crime; but if it did, this would not be a defence, as voluntary drunkonness'of whatever degree is no excuse for crime committed under its influence.</p> <p>3. The difficulty is great, if not insuperable, of establishing by satisfactory proof whether an impulse was or was not uncontrollable. But there was nothing in this case requiring the Circuit Judge to enter upon this subject.</p> <p>4. The Circuit Judge correctly charged the jury as follows: “In order to relieve himself from responsibility for a criminal act by reason of mental unsoundness, the prisoner must show that he was under a mental delusion by reason of mental disease and that at the time of the act lie did not know that the act he committed was wrong, or criminal, or punishable, either the one or the other. Because, notwithstanding his inind may be diseased, if he is still capable of forming a correct judgment as to the nature of the act as to its being morally or legally wrong, he is still responsible for his act and punishable as if no mental disease existed at all.”</p>
Judges: McGowan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerSourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.