State Highway Route No. 72
Citations
- 265 Pa. 369
- 108 A. 820
- 1919 Pa. LEXIS 557
Syllabus
<p>Road law — Opening and improvement — Damages — Rights of landowners.</p> <p>1. In the opening and improvement of public highways the landowners are entitled only to such redress as is given by statute, inasmuch as their claim is a matter of grace and not of constitutional right.</p> <p>Road law — Construction—Exercise of sovereign authority — Liability of Commonwealth for damages.</p> <p>2. The Commonwealth exercises its sovereign authority in the construction of public highways, and is not liable for damages occasioned thereby unless made so by express enactment.</p> <p>Road law — State highways — Change of grade — Damages—State Highway Act of May SI, 1911, P. L. Ifi8, Sec. 61.</p> <p>3. The Commonwealth is not liable for damages occasioned to abutting property by the change of grade of a State highway where no change is made in the horizontal lines of the road inasmuch as a change of grade does not constitute “a change of existing lines and location,” within the meaning of Section 16 of the State Highway Act of May 31,1911, P. L. 468, providing for the assessment of damages resulting to abutting property.</p> <p>Statutes — Construction—Title—Title broader than act itself.</p> <p>4. Although the title of a statute may be considered in construing the statute it cannot give vitality to a subject omitted from the body of the statute nor control the plain meaning of the language of the statute.</p> <p>Constitutional law —Talcing private property for public use — Compensation — Change of grade of highway — ■Article I, Section 10 —Road law.</p> <p>5. The change of grade of an existing highway which occasions damage to abutting property is not a taking or application of private property for public use within the inhibition of Section 10 of Article I of the Constitution, which provides “nor shall private property be taken or applied to public use without authority of law and without compensation being first made or secured.”</p> <p>Constitutional law■ — Talcing private
Judges: Brown, Frazer, Moschzisker, Simpson, Stewart, Walling
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Georgevich v. StraussThird Circuit· 1985-09-05· cited 96×
- Philadelphia AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1956-01-04· cited 22×
- Commonwealth v. CooperSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1923-05-23· cited 22×
- McFarland EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1954-05-24· cited 17×
- Cavalier AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1962-07-30· cited 16×
- Kerry v. CommonwealthSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1955-04-18· cited 3×
- Grand Lodge of Independent Order of Odd Fellows v. BakerSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1960-03-24· cited 3×
- Jones v. GarrodSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1966-01-04· cited 2×
- Georgevich v. StraussThird Circuit· 1985-09-30
- Mensch v. Columbia CountyColumbia County Court of Common Pleas· 1923-06-08
- Eyer v. Forks TownshipNorthampton County Court of Common Pleas· 1925-07-06
- Ligonier Borough v. DeedsWestmoreland County Court of Common Pleas· 1926-07-01
- Philadelphia Electric Co. v. CommonwealthPhiladelphia County Court of Common Pleas· 1933-02-20
- Cavanaugh's PetitionLehigh County Court of Common Pleas· 1934-05-21
- Petition of Library Co.Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas· 1934-07-27
- Commonwealth v. SemmelLehigh County Court of Common Pleas· 1938-06-13
- Jones v. Mt. Carmel Township School DistrictNorthumberland County Court of Common Pleas· 1943-01-04
- Dalton Street Railway Co. v. CommonwealthLackawanna County Court of Common Pleas· 1945-08-04
- Commonwealth v. ZeidensteinAlleghany County Court of Common Pleas· 1952-09-03
- Durante's PetitionJefferson County Court of Quarter Sessions· 1923-01-29
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. RibletSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1870-10-18· cited 52×
- Rich v. KeyserSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1867-02-04· cited 18×
- Snively v. Washington TownshipSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-05-20· cited 18×
- State Highway Route No. 72Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1919-01-03· cited 18×
- Wagner v. Township of SalzburgSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1890-03-03· cited 17×
- Jamison v. Cumberland CountySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1912-02-05· cited 16×
- Workman v. MifflinSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1858-07-01· cited 15×
- Yeager & German v. WeaverSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1870-03-31· cited 14×
- Halderman's AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1883-10-11· cited 12×
- Township of East Union v. ComreySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1882-05-01· cited 11×
- Eby's AppealSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1872-01-16· cited 10×
- Shoe v. Nether Providence TownshipSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-12-07· cited 8×
- Brink v. MarshSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1913-04-21· cited 8×
- Lamoreux v. County of LuzerneSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1887-04-25· cited 7×
- Jamison v. Cumberland CountySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1909-04-19· cited 6×
- Allison v. BigelowSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-10-15· cited 6×
Other cases named State Highway Route No. 72
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.