West Virginia Supreme Court· 3/12/2009
State Ex Rel. Smith v. McBride
Citations
- 681 S.E.2d 81
- 224 W. Va. 196
- 2009 W. Va. LEXIS 17
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- noting due to strength of evidence against defendant, third party’s confession was unlikely to change verdict
- recognizing trial court has discretion to determine credibility of new evidence
- evaluating credibility of new evidence and strength of other evidence of guilt in determining whether admission of confession would change trial outcome
- addressing the requirements for granting a new trial based on newly-discovered evidence
- addressing the requirements for granting a new trial based on newly-discovered evidence
- describing “actual innocence” as term of art developed in federal jurisprudence
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Davis, Albright, Status, McHugh
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Commonwealth v. PadillasSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-06-11· cited 248×
- Gould v. Commissioner of CorrectionSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2011-07-19· cited 30×
- Johnathon Lane Justiss, a/k/a Jonathan Lane Justiss v. Commonwealth of VirginiaCourt of Appeals of Virginia· 2012-12-11· cited 17×
- Lawyer Disciplinary Board v. Wendelyn A. ElswickWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2013-09-26· cited 3×
- State of West Virginia v. Leonard C. LewisWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2017-03-09· cited 2×
- William T. Widmyer v. David Ballard, WardenWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2015-05-15
- Timothy Stewart v. Patrick Mirandy, WardenWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2016-09-02
- State of West Virginia v. Benny W.West Virginia Supreme Court· 2019-10-18
- State of West Virginia v. WardWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2021-03-23
- Frank A. v. Donnie Ames, SuperintendentWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2021-11-19
- State of West Virginia v. N.D.West Virginia Supreme Court· 2022-04-20
- James DeGasperin v. Shelby Searls, Superintendent, Huttonsville Correctional CenterWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2024-10-22
- Jonathan Frame, Superintendent, Mt. Olive Correctional Complex v. Barry D. WhiteWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2024-11-12
- DeAndre Moore v. Jonathan Frame, Superintendent, Mount Olive Correctional ComplexWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2024-11-26
Cites
35 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Mathena v. HainesWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2006-06-28· cited 775×
- Dellinger v. StateTennessee Supreme Court· 2009-01-22· cited 702×
- Sells v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2003-03-12· cited 460×
- People v. CressMichigan Supreme Court· 2003-07-09· cited 269×
- State v. HamricWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1966-07-15· cited 107×
- Halstead v. HortonWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1894-01-27· cited 106×
- State v. FrazierWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1979-04-10· cited 96×
- United States v. Kamel Kamel and Musa KhabbasSeventh Circuit· 1992-06-16· cited 81×
- In Re Cesar L.West Virginia Supreme Court· 2007-10-25· cited 79×
- State Ex Rel. Postelwaite v. BechtoldWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1975-02-04· cited 78×
- Barreto-Barreto v. United StatesFirst Circuit· 2008-12-24· cited 77×
- State v. WoodallWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1989-07-06· cited 72×
- Elbert Blango v. Richard R. Thornburgh J. Michael Quinlan Gary L. Henman Mayor, Washington, D.C.Tenth Circuit· 1991-08-16· cited 53×
- State v. KnucklesWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1996-05-17· cited 53×
- State v. HedrickWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1999-02-22· cited 47×
- State v. JenkinsWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1995-12-11· cited 46×
- State v. StewartWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1977-12-20· cited 44×
- State v. CallowayWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2000-01-06· cited 39×
- Melson v. AllenEleventh Circuit· 2008-11-14· cited 39×
- Marriage of Rosen v. RosenWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2008-06-26· cited 37×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.