State ex rel. Mullen v. Howell
Citations
- 107 Wash. 167
- 181 P. 920
Syllabus
<p>Statutes (74)—Construction—Exceptions. The seventh amendment, art. 2, § 1, of the constitution, which reserves to the people a right to a referendum of all laws except such as are necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety or support of public institutions, is an expression of a reservation to pass upon all things not specified in the exception.</p> <p>Constitutional Law (24)—Statutes (54)—Construction. A law will not be held unconstitutional unless such holding is compelled.</p> <p>Constitutional Law (3)—Construction. Constitutional provisions must be interpreted with reference to the times and circumstances under which the constitution was framed.</p> <p>Statutes (2-3)—Initiative and Referendum—What Laws Subject to—“Act, Bill or Law”—Approving Amendment to Federal Constitution. The joint resolution of the legislature ratifying the prohibition amendment to the Federal constitution is subject to referendum, being an “act, bill or law” within the meaning of the seventh amendment of the constitution, art. 2, § 1, adopting the referendum form of government.</p> <p>Same (2-3). The authority for state action on a proposed amendment to the Federal constitution is found in the Federal and not the state constitution, and the power to question it being in Congress and not in the courts, the contention that the legislature had no power to act by resolution is nonjusticiable.</p> <p>Same (2-3). Article 5 of the Federal constitution, providing that a proposed amendment shall be valid when ratified by the legislatures of three-fourths of the states, means that the ratification shall be by the legislative power of the state, which, under the reserved power of referendum, includes the whole people as part of the law making power, and renders legislative action on a proposed amendment subject to a referendum.</p> <p>■Same (2-3). The adoption of the referendum form of government does not violate the Federal constitution, art. 4, § 4, guarantee
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- it is the act of the Legislature in adopting the measure, rather than the measure itself, that is referred to the voters
- ratification of federal prohibition amendment
- ratification of federal prohibition amendment
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Chadwick, Fullerton, MacKintosh, Parker, Tolman
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. ManussierWashington Supreme Court· 1996-08-08· cited 269×
- American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations v. EuCalifornia Supreme Court· 1984-08-27· cited 90×
- CLEAN v. StateWashington Supreme Court· 1996-12-20· cited 89×
- Brower v. StateWashington Supreme Court· 1998-12-24· cited 82×
- State Ex Rel. Humiston v. MeyersWashington Supreme Court· 1963-04-11· cited 81×
- State Ex Rel. Distilled Spirits Institute, Inc. v. KinnearWashington Supreme Court· 1972-01-20· cited 63×
- City of Seattle v. Mighty Movers, Inc.Washington Supreme Court· 2004-09-09· cited 41×
- 1000 Friends of Washington v. McFarlandWashington Supreme Court· 2006-12-21· cited 35×
- 1000 Friends v. McFarlandWashington Supreme Court· 2006-12-21· cited 35×
- Washington State Labor Council v. ReedWashington Supreme Court· 2003-04-03· cited 33×
- Grant County Fire Protection District No. 5 v. City of Moses LakeWashington Supreme Court· 2002-03-14· cited 28×
- State Ex Rel. O'Connell v. KramerWashington Supreme Court· 1968-01-23· cited 26×
- State Ex Rel. Pennock v. CoeWashington Supreme Court· 1953-05-07· cited 25×
- State Ex Rel. O'Connell v. MeyersWashington Supreme Court· 1957-12-24· cited 23×
- State ex rel. Short v. HinkleWashington Supreme Court· 1921-05-26· cited 23×
- Yelle v. KramerWashington Supreme Court· 1974-02-22· cited 21×
- Save Our State Park v. HordykCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1993-08-19· cited 17×
- Whittemore v. TerralSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1919-11-17· cited 11×
- Save Our State Park v. Board of Clallam County CommissionersCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1994-07-15· cited 8×
- Clean v. StateWashington Supreme Court· 1997-01-13· cited 6×
Cites
9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Noble State Bank v. HaskellSupreme Court· 1911-01-03· cited 496×
- Maxwell v. DowSupreme Court· 1900-03-12· cited 321×
- Ohio Ex Rel. Davis v. HildebrantSupreme Court· 1916-06-12· cited 87×
- People v. HardingMichigan Supreme Court· 1884-04-23· cited 85×
- State ex rel. Case v. HowellWashington Supreme Court· 1915-04-22· cited 42×
- State ex rel. Davis v. HildebrantOhio Supreme Court· 1916-04-18· cited 20×
- Herbring v. BrownOregon Supreme Court· 1919-04-29· cited 17×
- Schrader ex rel. Schrader v. PolleySouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1910-06-18· cited 14×
- Boyers v. CraneWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1865-07-15· cited 12×
Other cases named State ex rel. Mullen v. Howell
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.