Smith v. Jackson Township
Citations
- 26 Pa. Super. 234
- 1904 Pa. Super. LEXIS 297
Syllabus
<p>Negligence — Conflicting statements of witness — Province of jury.</p> <p>It is for the jury to determine what a witness means when he uses language warranting distinct and opposite inferences. They must determine his meaning not only from his words, but from his manner and all the surrounding circumstances, and find whether he was careful or careless.</p> <p>Seeming inconsistencies in a party’s testimony do not necessarily lead to the conclusion that he is untruthful; nor, where his testimony relates to a subject as to which the burden of proof is on the opposite party, will they, ordinarily, warrant the court in instructing the jury to reject those parts of it which make in his favor, and to base their verdict on those parts of it which seem to make against him. Under these circumstances the case must go to the jury, whose province it is to reconcile conflicting statements, whether of the same or different witnesses, or to draw the line between them and say which shall prevail.</p> <p>Negligence — Bridge—Hole in bridge — Contributory negligence — Province of court and jury.</p> <p>In an action against a township to recover damages for personal injuries, it appeared that while plaintiff was driving over a bridge belonging to the township, his horse stepped through a hole about five inches wide and between fifteen and twenty inches long, and plaintiff was thrown from his wagon and injured. The hole had been in the bridge for about three weeks before the accident, and plaintiff had observed it as he went to and fro daily, but on the day preceding a person, without the direction or knowledge of the supervisors, had nailed a board over the hole, a repair of which the plaintiff had notice when first crossing the bridge on the morning of the accident. This board was removed and the hole uncovered before’ his return, which was an hour or two later. A number of milk cans in the wagon prevented the use of a seat, and the plaintiff was riding on one of the cans. The plain
Judges: Beaver, Henderson, Morrison, Orlady, Porter, Rice, Smith
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
2 cases in this archive cite this case.
Cites
11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Ely v. Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis RailwaySupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1893-11-06· cited 89×
- Brown v. WhiteSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-04-21· cited 42×
- Bruch v. City of PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-07-15· cited 34×
- Iseminger v. York Haven Water & Power Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-07-09· cited 22×
- Graham v. PhiladelphiaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-02-14· cited 18×
- Strader v. MonroeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-05-19· cited 15×
- Wall v. PittsburgSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1903-01-05· cited 13×
- Butcher v. PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-03-03· cited 11×
- McHugh v. KerrSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1904-02-29· cited 6×
- Chilton v. CarbondaleSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1894-03-26· cited 4×
- Smith v. Jackson TownshipSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1902-05-22· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.