Skip to main content

Smith v. Donahoe

Citations

  • 13 S.D. 334
  • 83 N.W. 264
  • 1900 S.D. LEXIS 142

Syllabus

<p>1. Under Laws 1889, O’. 26, §8, providing Unit in case of the sale of mortgaged chattels on foreclosure the officer shall pay — First, all costs and expenses of the sale; s.-emtd. th mortgaged d bt; and, third, shall pay the balance to the own r of the propirl.v, — a junior mortgagee of the property, whose mor'gngo is due, is posses-u d of the mortgagor’s right to a remaining surplus, nnd miy maintain trover against an officer refusing to pay such surplus to him in satisfaction of his claim.</p> <p>2. Where a junior chattel mortgage contains a clause covering- ‘-all other goods not listed above, in the bather shop,” etc., of the mortgagor, such clause is sufficient to include “a subscription list for tickets,” described in the senior mortgage, hut not specifically mentioned in the junior instrument; and hence the two mortgag-es sufficiently cover the same property so as to entitle a junior mortgagee to a surplus remaining on sale of the property, after satisfaction of the senior mortgage.</p> <p>3. Where a junior chattel mortgage fails to include in its description of the property “a subscription list for tickets” named in a senior mortgage, and on the trial of an action by the junior mortgagee to recover from an officer a surplus remaining after foreclosure sale under, and satisfaction of, the senior mortgage, it appears that the subscription list was worthless, there is not such a variance in the descriptions of the property in the several instruments as to defeat plaintiff’s recovery.</p> <p>4. Where mortgaged chattels are sold by the sheriff under foreclosure proceedings, and the mortgage satisfied, a junior incumbrancer may maintain trover to recover a surplus remaining in the officer’s hands, and is not rrstrieted to a suit in equity, since a mortgagee’s interest is one which may be protected by an action at law, though he have only a lien on the property, and not title thereto.</p> <p>5. Where, on trial of tin action by a junior mortgagee of chattels to re

Judges: Corson

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

3 cases in this archive cite this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.