Sixth Circuit· 12/2/2005
Smith v. Cupp
Citations
- 430 F.3d 766
- 2005 WL 3242150
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that unlike Brosseau, where there is no suspicion of a firearm, where the crime did not involve infliction or threatened infliction of serious physical harm, and where there is no imminent threat to others, a clearly established right was violated
- holding that unlike Brosseau, where there is no suspicion of a firearm, where the crime did not involve infliction or threatened infliction of serious physical harm, and where there is no imminent threat to others, a clearly established right was violated
- determining that a jury could find an officer outside the fleeing vehicle was never in its path and fired his weapon after the vehicle had passed and thus was not in immediate danger
- holding deadly force under the circumstances was contrary to law because the officer shot the suspect after he drove passed the officer and there was no immediate danger to anyone in the vicinity
- noting that the officer’s “use of force was made even more unreasonable by the fact that [the decedent] had been cooperative up to this point, and was arrested for the nonviolent offence of making harassing phone calls”
- noting that the officer’s “use of force was made even more unreasonable by the fact that [the decedent] had been' cooperative up to this point, and was arrested for the nonviolent offence of making harassing phone calls”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Duplantier, Merritt, Rogers
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
59 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Mullenix v. LunaSupreme Court· 2015-11-09· cited 3,438×
- Scott Peatross v. City of MemphisSixth Circuit· 2016-03-29· cited 710×
- Peggy Sigley v. City of Parma HeightsSixth Circuit· 2006-02-10· cited 437×
- Lytle v. Bexar County, Tex.Fifth Circuit· 2009-02-25· cited 299×
- Geraldine Livermore, Personal Representative for the Estate of Roland E. Rohm, Deceased v. Daniel Lubelan and Jerry EllsworthSixth Circuit· 2007-02-07· cited 253×
- Morrow v. MeachumFifth Circuit· 2019-03-08· cited 214×
- Cordova v. AragonTenth Circuit· 2009-06-17· cited 178×
- Leona Mullins v. Oscar CyranekSixth Circuit· 2015-11-09· cited 178×
- Debbie Latits v. Lowell PhillipsSixth Circuit· 2017-12-27· cited 161×
- Edward Godawa v. David ByrdSixth Circuit· 2015-08-19· cited 105×
- Estate of Kirby v. DuvaSixth Circuit· 2008-06-27· cited 93×
- Than Orn v. City of TacomaNinth Circuit· 2020-02-03· cited 93×
- Davenport v. CauseySixth Circuit· 2008-04-04· cited 77×
- Williams v. City of Grosse Pointe ParkSixth Circuit· 2007-08-03· cited 77×
- Robert Kennedy v. City of CincinnatiSixth Circuit· 2010-02-16· cited 69×
- Melissa Hearring v. Karen SliwowskiSixth Circuit· 2013-03-27· cited 67×
- Jamila Russell v. Superior Court of the Virgin IThird Circuit· 2018-09-25· cited 67×
- William Cass v. City of DaytonSixth Circuit· 2014-10-16· cited 62×
- Ruby Hicks v. Doris ScottSixth Circuit· 2020-05-01· cited 53×
- Lena Davenport v. Borough of HomesteadThird Circuit· 2017-08-29· cited 49×
Cites
18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Graham v. ConnorSupreme Court· 1989-05-15· cited 16,485×
- Anderson v. CreightonSupreme Court· 1987-06-25· cited 12,768×
- Tennessee v. GarnerSupreme Court· 1985-03-27· cited 4,272×
- United States v. RobinsonSupreme Court· 1973-12-11· cited 3,538×
- Johnson v. JonesSupreme Court· 1995-06-12· cited 2,857×
- Brosseau v. HaugenSupreme Court· 2004-12-13· cited 2,748×
- United States v. LanierSupreme Court· 1997-03-31· cited 2,070×
- Philip Berryman v. Dean Rieger, C. Kukla, Diane HolzheuerSixth Circuit· 1998-07-06· cited 545×
- Estate of Tori Carter Brenda Chambers v. City of Detroit, Donald Hollins, LieutenantSixth Circuit· 2005-05-27· cited 416×
- Patricia Smith, Individually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Brent Robin Smith v. James Freland Peter Schulcz and the City of Springdale, OhioSixth Circuit· 1992-01-06· cited 336×
- Patricia Scott v. Clay County, Tennessee Chinn Anderson Billy Pierce Michael ThompsonSixth Circuit· 2000-03-01· cited 321×
- Glenn W. Phelps, Jr. v. Robert M. Coy, Jr., Christin StutesSixth Circuit· 2002-04-10· cited 276×
- Cheryl D. Lyons v. City of Xenia, Christine Keith, Officer Matthew Foubert, OfficerSixth Circuit· 2005-08-04· cited 269×
- Christopher Sample v. Jason BaileySixth Circuit· 2005-05-09· cited 221×
- Mildred Robinson v. Daniel ArruguetaEleventh Circuit· 2005-07-07· cited 136×
- McLenagan v. KarnesFourth Circuit· 1994-06-30· cited 124×
- Dianne Troupe v. Sarasota County, FloridaEleventh Circuit· 2005-08-03· cited 100×
- Fultz v. WhittakerSixth Circuit· 2004-02-24· cited 2×
Other cases named Smith v. Cupp
7 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Smith v. CuppCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1982-02-08· cited 1×
- Smith v. CuppNinth Circuit· 1976-10-21
- Smith v. CuppNinth Circuit· 1984-05-01
- Smith v. CuppSixth Circuit· 2005-12-02
- Smith v. CuppCourt of Appeals of Oregon· 1973-08-22
- Smith v. CuppSupreme Court· 1972-10-10
- Smith v. CuppSupreme Court· 1984-10-01
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.