Tenth Circuit· 3/7/2006
Self v. Oliva
Citations
- 439 F.3d 1227
- 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 5710
- 2006 WL 541248
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a claim for gatekeeper liability is actionable “where the need for additional treatment [] is obvious”
- holding that the subjective component cannot be satisfied if the medical professional “provides a level of care consistent with the symptoms presented by the inmate.”
- holding that Farmer’s “subjective component is not satisfied[ ] absent an extraordinary degree of neglect”
- holding that Farmer’s “subjective component is not satisfied[ ] absent an extraordinary degree of neglect”
- concluding that where a prison doctor responds to an “obvious risk” with “patently unreasonable” treatment it is appropriate to infer conscious disregard
- recognizing that an Eighth Amendment claim may arise where “a medical professional completely denies care although presented with recognizable symptoms which potentially create a medical emergency”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Murphy, McWilliams, Tymkovich
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
61 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Tyrone Petties v. Imhotep CarterSeventh Circuit· 2016-08-25· cited 1,624×
- Christopher Pyles v. Magid FahimSeventh Circuit· 2014-11-13· cited 1,225×
- Lewis Rhinehart v. Debra ScuttSixth Circuit· 2018-06-28· cited 689×
- Burke v. RegaladoTenth Circuit· 2019-08-20· cited 411×
- Cox v. GlanzTenth Circuit· 2015-09-08· cited 342×
- Strain v. RegaladoTenth Circuit· 2020-10-09· cited 212×
- Vasquez v. DavisTenth Circuit· 2018-02-23· cited 209×
- Serna v. Colorado Department of CorrectionsTenth Circuit· 2006-07-26· cited 208×
- Cardoso v. CalboneTenth Circuit· 2007-06-18· cited 204×
- Yu Kikumura v. OsagieTenth Circuit· 2006-09-08· cited 182×
- Redmond v. CrowtherTenth Circuit· 2018-02-09· cited 171×
- Al-Turki v. RobinsonTenth Circuit· 2014-08-12· cited 152×
- Lucas v. Turn Key Health ClinicsTenth Circuit· 2023-01-20· cited 152×
- Crowson v. Washington County State, UtahTenth Circuit· 2020-12-29· cited 136×
- Quintana v. Santa Fe County Board of Comm.Tenth Circuit· 2020-08-28· cited 129×
- Clark v. ColbertTenth Circuit· 2018-07-17· cited 87×
- GeoMetWatch v. BehuninTenth Circuit· 2022-06-29· cited 75×
- Glover v. GartmanD. New Mexico· 2012-09-27· cited 68×
- Paugh v. Uintah CountyTenth Circuit· 2022-09-07· cited 64×
- Lance v. Board of County CommissionersTenth Circuit· 2021-01-19· cited 62×
Cites
11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Farmer v. BrennanSupreme Court· 1994-06-06· cited 28,443×
- Estelle v. GambleSupreme Court· 1976-11-30· cited 28,035×
- Perkins v. Kansas Department of CorrectionsTenth Circuit· 1999-01-27· cited 821×
- Sealock v. State Of ColoradoTenth Circuit· 2000-07-11· cited 778×
- Bones v. Honeywell International, Inc.Tenth Circuit· 2004-04-23· cited 712×
- Mata v. SaizTenth Circuit· 2005-10-21· cited 676×
- Oxendine v. KaplanTenth Circuit· 2001-03-06· cited 420×
- Annett v. University of KansasTenth Circuit· 2004-06-15· cited 252×
- Sosebee v. MurphyFourth Circuit· 1986-08-05· cited 237×
- Phillips v. CalhounTenth Circuit· 1992-02-11· cited 156×
- Larry Ledoux v. Steven J. Davies, Secretary of Corrections Raymond Roberts, Warden Robert D. Hannigan, Warden, Hutchinson Correctional FacilityTenth Circuit· 1992-04-24· cited 143×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.