SecurAmerica Business Credit v. Southland Transportation Co., LLC

Syllabus

This is the fourth appeal in a case primarily concerned with whether two individual defendants are liable on loan guaranties. Following the third appeal, we remanded the case to the trial court to determine: (1) whether one of the defendants is liable under a Guaranty of Validity of Collateral (\GVC\) (2) whether prejudgment interest should be awarded to the lender on personal guaranties both defendants signed and (3) whether the lender is entitled to recover additional attorney's fees incurred in enforcing the guaranties since the previous appeal. On remand following the third appeal, the trial court found that the defendant was not liable on the GVC. The trial court also found that the lender was not entitled to prejudgment interest because the lender committed fraud, and it declined to award the lender any additional attorney's fees. Although the defendants prevailed on all three issues, they appeal, seeking reconsideration of this court's determination in an earlier appeal that the defendants failed to prove their claim of fraud, which would relieve them of any liability. The lender counters, insisting that this court's previous decision, wherein we affirmed the trial court's determination that the defendants failed to prove fraud, is the law of the case. The lender also raises its own issues for our consideration, including whether the trial court's findings of fact and conclusions of law concerning fraud, as stated in the final order drafted by counsel for the defendants, reflects the trial court's independent judgment. A careful review of the trial court's oral ruling from the bench and the written order, as well as previous findings of fact made by the trial court, leads us to conclude that some of the findings of fact stated in the final order do not reflect the trial court's independent judgment. Therefore, the presumption under Tenn. R. App. P. 13(d) that a trial court's specific findings of fact are supported by the evidence shall be limited to those fin