Secombe v. Railroad Co.
Citations
- 90 U.S. 108
- 23 L. Ed. 67
- 23 Wall. 108
- 1874 U.S. LEXIS 1298
Syllabus
<p>1. When the question is whether, under the constitution and laws of a particular State, a company professing to be a corporation, is legally so, this court will receive as conclusive of the question, the decision of the highest court of the State deciding, in a case identical in principle, in favor of the corporate existence.</p> <p>2. The taking of private property in order that a railroad may be made, belongs to the class of things which in proper cases are to be regarded as public necessities.</p> <p>3. The mode of exercising the right of eminent domain, in the absence of any provision of organic law prescribing a contrary course, is within the discretion of the legislature. There is no limitation upon the power of the legislature in this respect if tho purpose be a public one and just compensation be paid or tendered to the owner for the property taken.</p> <p>4. A judgment of condemnation rendered by a competent court, charged. with a special statutory jurisdiction, and when all the facts necessary to the exercise of the jurisdiction are shown to exist, is no more subject to impeachment in a collateral proceeding than the judgment of any other court of exclusive jurisdiction.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the Legislature has broad authority to create eminent domain procedures
- holding that the Legislature has broad authority to create eminent domain procedures
- holding that the Legislature has broad authority to create eminent domain procedures
- “there is no limitation” upon the power of the sovereign to take private property for public use if just compensation is paid to the former owner
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Davis
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
38 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bauman v. RossSupreme Court· 1897-05-24· cited 467×
- Huling v. Kaw Valley Railway & Improvement Co.Supreme Court· 1889-05-13· cited 118×
- City of Dallas v. VSC, LLCTexas Supreme Court· 2011-07-01· cited 77×
- Oregon Railway & Navigation Co. v. MosierOregon Supreme Court· 1887-02-19· cited 27×
- Dallas v. HallockOregon Supreme Court· 1904-02-01· cited 26×
- Gano v. Minneapolis & St. Louis RailroadSupreme Court of Iowa· 1901-10-17· cited 22×
- United States v. BeatyW.D. Virginia· 1912-08-09· cited 18×
- Briscoe v. RudolphSupreme Court· 1911-05-29· cited 17×
- United States v. HessEighth Circuit· 1934-05-21· cited 17×
- Port of New York Authority v. HemingSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1961-01-23· cited 17×
- Kardo Co. v. AdamsSixth Circuit· 1916-02-18· cited 17×
- State ex rel. Moody v. BakerSupreme Court of Florida· 1884-01-15· cited 16×
- Cory v. Chicago, Burlington & Kansas City Railway Co.Supreme Court of Missouri· 1889-10-15· cited 13×
- Olson v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1933-08-17· cited 12×
- Simpson v. Board of SupervisorsSupreme Court of Iowa· 1917-05-22· cited 12×
- Kohlasch v. New York State Thruway AuthorityS.D. New York· 1980-01-07· cited 11×
- Waynesburg Southern Railroad Company v. LemleyWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1970-12-15· cited 10×
- Tuttle v. MooreCourt Of Appeals Of Indian Territory· 1901-10-05· cited 10×
- Equitrans, L.P. v. 0.56 Acres More or Less of Permanent EasementN.D. West Virginia· 2015-11-18· cited 9×
- Bronx Chamber of Commerce, Inc. v. FullenNew York Supreme Court· 1940-05-24· cited 8×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.