Skip to main content

Schuler v. Schuler

Citations

  • 39 Pa. Super. 635
  • 1909 Pa. Super. LEXIS 547

Syllabus

<p>Equity — Jurisdiction — Legal title — Demurrer—Answer—Easement— Contract.</p> <p>1. A demurrer to a bill in equity admits the material facts averred in the bill, and where such facts show a legal title in the complainant it is not a prerequisite to the enforcement in equity of equitable rights incident thereto that the complainant’s legal title be established in an action at law.</p> <p>2. The jurisdiction of a court of equity to restrain or prevent the permission or continuance of acts contrary to law and prejudicial to the rights of individuals as applied to a bill to restrain the obstruction of an easement, is not ousted by an answer denying the plaintiff’s legal right.</p> <p>3. Where two landowners enter into an agreement in writing relating to the flow of surface water, and there are reciprocal covenants, and a dispute arises as to the construction of the instrument, but there is no dispute as to any extrinsic fact affecting its construction, a court of equity has jurisdiction to determine the construction of the instrument.</p> <p>4. Where in such an instrument it is agreed that one of the parties shall have the right to flow the surface water as it has been wont to flow for many years, without any provision making such right conditional, the inference is that the parties intended the right to vest at once; and this inference is not weakened by a covenant of the party securing the right, to fill up all gullies and ditches washed out by the waters caused by the falling of rain or the melting of snow on his own premises then existing, or that might thereafter be washed out, so as not to increase the flow of said waters of the defendant’s premises, for any unreasonable length of time. The obligation to fill the gullies is a continuing one.</p>

Judges: Beaver, Head, Henderson, Morrison, Orlady, Porter, Rice

Read full opinion on CourtListener

Cited by

2 cases in this archive cite this case.

Cites

1 case in this archive is cited by this case.

Other cases with this name

Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).

This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.