S. S. Pass Ry. Co. v. Trich
Citations
- 117 Pa. 390
- 11 A. 627
- 1887 Pa. LEXIS 273
Syllabus
<p>1. When, in an action for negligence, the fact is undisputed in the evidence that the injury received was inflicted by an intervening agency over which the defendant had no control, the question of remote or proximate cause .must be determined by the court and the jury instructed accordingly.</p> <p>2. The plaintiff was upon the rear platform and about to enter a streetcar, when the driver whipped up to avoid a collision with a runaway horse and carriage. The abrupt jolt communicated to the car threw the plaintiff to the ground, when she was immediately struck by the runaway and injured: Held, that the court, upon request, should have instructed the jury that, even if the car-driver was guilty of negligence, such negligence was not the proximate cause of the injury and the plaintiff could not recover.</p>
Judges: Clark, Gordon, Green, Opeen, Paxson, Sterrett, Trunkey, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
22 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Kuhns v. BruggerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1957-10-07· cited 163×
- Chicago, B. & Q. R. v. GelvinEighth Circuit· 1916-11-10· cited 70×
- Lemos v. MaddenWyoming Supreme Court· 1921-09-09· cited 69×
- Missouri Pacific Railway Co. v. ColumbiaSupreme Court of Kansas· 1902-07-05· cited 64×
- Teis v. Smuggler Mining Co.Eighth Circuit· 1907-12-09· cited 33×
- Home Oil & Gas Co. v. DabneySupreme Court of Kansas· 1909-04-10· cited 28×
- Bruggeman v. City of YorkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-06-30· cited 27×
- Central of Georgia Railway Co. v. PriceSupreme Court of Georgia· 1898-12-14· cited 23×
- Guca v. Pittsburgh Railways Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1951-05-23· cited 19×
- Behling v. Southwest Penn. Pipe LinesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1894-03-26· cited 17×
- Swanson v. CrandallSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-07-16· cited 14×
- Ward v. Inter-Island Steam Navigation Co.Hawaii Supreme Court· 1914-03-17· cited 14×
- Boss v. Northern Pacific RailroadNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 1891-07-31· cited 14×
- Pittsburgh Forge & Iron Co. v. Dravo Contracting Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1922-01-03· cited 13×
- Hoehle v. Allegheny Heating Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-07-23· cited 10×
- Lewiston Milling Co. v. CardiffNinth Circuit· 1920-07-06· cited 6×
- Scott v. Allegheny Valley Railway Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1896-01-06· cited 4×
- Robb v. Pennsylvania Co. for Insurance on Lives & Granting AnnuitiesSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1897-01-18· cited 4×
- Wise v. Western Union Telegraph Co.Superior Court of Delaware· 1934-04-26· cited 4×
- McCabe v. PhiladelphiaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1907-02-25
Cites
3 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.