Ruth v. Witherspoon-Englar Co.
Citations
- 98 Kan. 179
- 157 P. 403
- 1916 Kan. LEXIS 41
Syllabus
<p>SYLLABUS BY THE COURT.</p> <p>1. Workmen’s Compensation Act — Compensation for Injury Received in “Course of Employment” Only — Not Augmented by Unskillful Surgical Treatment. In an action under the workmen’s compensation act a recovery can be had only upon the basis of disability to labor resulting from the injury received in the course of employment, without the intervention of an independent cause, the separate consequences of which admit of definite ascertainment. It can not be augmented by the fact that the disabling effects of the injury are increased or prolonged by incompetent or negligent surgical treatment, even where the employer is responsible therefor.</p> <p>2. Same — Evidence—Disability—“Course of Employment” — Unskillful Surgery. The evidence is held not to justify a finding that the permanent character of an employee’s disability is the result of the injury received in the course of his employment, rather than of unskillful surgical treatment, and the verdict is set aside for that reason and because the issue relating to malpractice was not sufficiently presented to the jury.</p> <p>3. Same — Evidence—Manner in which Injury Was Received Irrelevant. In an action under the workmen’s compensation act evidence of the manner in which the injury was received is ordinarily irrelevant, and testimony given in that connection of ill treatment of the plaintiff by the foreman under whom he worked may be prejudicial as tending to arouse feeling against the defendant in the minds of the jury.</p>
Judges: Mason
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
17 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Schumacher v. LeslieSupreme Court of Missouri· 1950-10-09· cited 73×
- Fauver v. BellSupreme Court of Virginia· 1951-06-18· cited 70×
- Oleszek v. Ford Motor Co.Michigan Supreme Court· 1922-02-08· cited 30×
- Bidnick v. Armour & Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1923-04-07· cited 20×
- Duncan v. W. M. Davidson Construction Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1951-01-27· cited 11×
- Fernandez v. GantzDistrict of Columbia· 1953-07-11· cited 11×
- Roberts v. KrupkaSupreme Court of Kansas· 1990-04-13· cited 10×
- Evans v. Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Co.E.D. Virginia· 1965-08-05· cited 8×
- Mitchell v. PeasleeSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1948-12-13· cited 7×
- Ellamar Mining Co. v. PossusNinth Circuit· 1918-01-07· cited 7×
- Dinoni v. Vulcan Coal Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1931-04-11· cited 7×
- Cooke v. BuntenSupreme Court of Kansas· 1932-06-04· cited 7×
- Huntoon v. PritchardAppellate Court of Illinois· 1935-05-17· cited 5×
- Oliver v. ChristopherSupreme Court of Kansas· 1916-07-08· cited 4×
- Roberts v. KrupkaCourt of Appeals of Kansas· 1990-04-13· cited 3×
- Ruth v. Witherspoon-Englar Co.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1917-05-12· cited 2×
- Parchefsky v. Kroll Bros.Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1934-11-15· cited 1×
Other cases named Ruth v. Witherspoon-Englar Co.
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.