Russell v. Sebastian
Citations
- 233 U.S. 195
- 34 S. Ct. 517
- 58 L. Ed. 912
- 1914 U.S. LEXIS 1281
Syllabus
<p>In determining the question of impairment under the contract clause of the Constitution it is the duty of this court to determine for itself the nature and extent of rights acquired under prior legislative or constitutional action.</p> <p>The state court having construed a statutory or constitutional provision, which gave specified privileges in regard to public utilities in a certain class of municipalities under specified conditions without specifying the persons or corporations who could avail thereof or the method of acceptance, to the effect that the grant became effective in any municipality within the designated class by the party accepting it as if it had been made specially to the accepting party, this court follows such construction in regard to § 19 of art. XI of the constitution of 1879 of California as amended in 1884.</p> <p>When the State declares that it is bound if its. offer to grant a privilege, which plainly contemplates the establishment of a plant and the assumption of a duty to perform the services incident to a public ■ utility, is accepted, the grant resulting from the acceptance constitutes a contract apd vests a property right in the accepting party which is within the protection of the contract clause of the Federal Constitution.</p> <p>The rule that public grants are to be construed strictly in favor of the public, and ambiguities are to be resolved against the grantee, is a salutary one to frustrate efforts through skilful wording of the grant by interested parties; but the rule does not deny to public offers a fair and reasonable interpretation or justify withholding that which the grant was intended to convey.</p> <p>An offer of the State to allow parties, ready to serve municipalities with gas or water, provisions for conveying the gas or water, is to be given •a practical common-sense construction; and the breadth of the offer is commensurate with the requirements of the undertaking invited.'</p> <p>■Where the constitution-of the
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- public grants to be given a \fair and reasonable\ interpretation that gives effect to what it \satisfactorily appears\ the government intended to convey
- public grants to be given a “fair and reasonable” interpretation that gives effect to what it “satisfactorily appears” the government intended to convey
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hughes
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
72 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. Winstar Corp.Supreme Court· 1996-07-01· cited 938×
- People v. Ocean Shore Railroad, Inc.California Supreme Court· 1948-08-13· cited 135×
- Dennis Melancon v. City of New Orleans, etFifth Circuit· 2012-12-18· cited 112×
- Jacks v. City of Santa BarbaraCalifornia Supreme Court· 2017-06-29· cited 106×
- United States v. GoltraSupreme Court· 1941-02-03· cited 89×
- New York Electric Lines Co. v. Empire City Subway Co.Supreme Court· 1914-11-30· cited 89×
- In Re PetersenCalifornia Supreme Court· 1958-10-31· cited 88×
- Dairyland Greyhound Park, Inc. v. DoyleWisconsin Supreme Court· 2006-07-14· cited 81×
- City of Mesa v. Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement & Power DistrictArizona Supreme Court· 1962-07-05· cited 75×
- City of Los Angeles v. Los Angeles Gas & Electric Corp.Supreme Court· 1919-12-08· cited 72×
- State Highway Commissioner v. Detroit City ControllerMichigan Supreme Court· 1951-10-01· cited 64×
- Southern California Gas Co. v. City of Los AngelesCalifornia Supreme Court· 1958-08-29· cited 61×
- State Ex Rel. Rich v. Idaho Power Co.Idaho Supreme Court· 1959-10-02· cited 45×
- In Re QuinnCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1973-11-19· cited 45×
- Roosevelt Raceway, Inc. v. MonaghanNew York Court of Appeals· 1961-03-23· cited 42×
- Lyon v. FlournoyCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1969-04-14· cited 33×
- State Ex Rel. City of Albuquerque v. LavenderNew Mexico Supreme Court· 1961-07-13· cited 32×
- Mahon v. Pennsylvania Coal Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1922-06-24· cited 31×
- In Re BorchertWashington Supreme Court· 1961-02-16· cited 30×
- Cuyahoga Metropolitan Housing Authority v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2003-09-22· cited 30×
Cites
17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Walla Walla City v. Walla Walla Water Co.Supreme Court· 1898-11-14· cited 378×
- New Orleans Gas Co. v. Louisiana Light Co.Supreme Court· 1885-12-07· cited 323×
- Atlantic Coast Line Railroad v. City of GoldsboroSupreme Court· 1914-02-24· cited 284×
- Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. North Carolina Corporation Comm'nSupreme Court· 1907-04-29· cited 240×
- City Railway Co. v. Citizens' Street RailroadSupreme Court· 1897-04-19· cited 125×
- Knoxville Water Co. v. KnoxvilleSupreme Court· 1906-01-02· cited 124×
- New Orleans Water-Works Co. v. RiversSupreme Court· 1885-12-07· cited 103×
- Douglas v. KentuckySupreme Court· 1897-11-29· cited 88×
- City of Louisville v. Cumberland Telephone & Telegraph Co.Supreme Court· 1912-05-13· cited 86×
- United States v. Denver & Rio Grande Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1893-10-23· cited 77×
- Grand Trunk Western Railway Co. v. City of South BendSupreme Court· 1913-02-24· cited 74×
- Dubuque & Pacific Railroad v. LitchfieldSupreme Court· 1860-04-18· cited 66×
- Slidell v. GrandjeanSupreme Court· 1884-03-03· cited 66×
- Boise Artesian Hot & Cold Water Co. v. Boise CitySupreme Court· 1913-06-16· cited 61×
- City of Minneapolis v. Minneapolis Street Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1910-01-01· cited 54×
- Madera Water Works v. MaderaSupreme Court· 1913-04-28· cited 42×
- Detroit Citizens' Street Railway Co. v. Detroit RailwaySupreme Court· 1898-05-23· cited 29×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.