Rogers v. Hennepin County
Citations
- 240 U.S. 184
- 36 S. Ct. 265
- 60 L. Ed. 594
- 1916 U.S. LEXIS 1441
Syllabus
<p>Where the state court does not decide against plaintiff in error upon an independent state ground, but, deeming the Federal question to be before it, actually entertains it and decides it adversely, this court has jurisdiction to review the final judgment under § 237, Jud. Code.</p> <p>The state Court having stated in a per curiam opinion that this' ease was controlled by the judgment in another similar case in which it entertained and decided the same Federal questions as to constitutionality of the tax sought to be enjoined, held that although there may have been other questions involved in this case, the judgment did not rest upon an independent state ground.</p> <p>Memberships in exchanges, such as those involved' in this action, are property notwithstanding restrictions upon their use, and nothing . in the Federal Constitution prevents their being taxed.</p> <p>Whether memberships in exchanges are in fact taxable under the state statutes is a matter of local law.</p> <p>Memberships in an incorporated exchange, as property of the respective members, are distinct from the assets of the corporation, and taxing the members on their memberships and the corporation on its assets does not amount to double taxation.</p> <p>The correct valuation of property is a matter for the taxing officials; and, where there is no charge of denial of opportunity to be heard.</p> <p>■ this court does not sit to review their judgment.</p> <p>Memberships in an Exchange represent rights and privileges to be exercised at the exchange where located, and it is competent for a State to fix the situs of memberships of both residents and nonresidents for the purpose of taxation at the place where the exchange is located, and in so doing it does not deprive non-resident members of their property without due process of law.</p> <p>The State has a broad discretion as to tax exemptions, and the taxa-</p> <p>. tion of. memberships in association conducting exchanges in which business transaction
Judges: Hughes, McReynolds
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
22 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Orr v. OrrSupreme Court· 1979-03-05· cited 714×
- Miller Brothers Co. v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1954-05-03· cited 331×
- Farmers Loan & Trust Co. v. MinnesotaSupreme Court· 1930-01-06· cited 313×
- Indiana Ex Rel. Anderson v. BrandSupreme Court· 1938-01-31· cited 273×
- Baldwin v. MissouriSupreme Court· 1930-05-26· cited 186×
- Citizens Nat. Bank of Cincinnati v. DurrSupreme Court· 1921-11-07· cited 50×
- Virginia v. Imperial Coal Sales Co.Supreme Court· 1934-11-05· cited 45×
- Schuylkill Trust Co. v. PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 1938-01-03· cited 45×
- Grayson v. HarrisSupreme Court· 1925-03-02· cited 34×
- New York Ex Rel. Whitney v. GravesSupreme Court· 1937-01-04· cited 33×
- Miller Bros. v. MarylandSupreme Court· 1954-04-05· cited 29×
- California v. Deseret Water, Oil & Irrigation Co.Supreme Court· 1917-03-26· cited 18×
- Tyler v. Dane CountyW.D. Wisconsin· 1923-05-28· cited 16×
- Dewar v. BrooksD. Nevada· 1936-10-21· cited 10×
- County of Grand Forks v. Cream of Wheat Co.North Dakota Supreme Court· 1918-11-30· cited 10×
- Barron-Leggett Elec., Inc. v. Dept. of RevenueCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1976-05-19· cited 7×
- Stevenson v. MetskerSupreme Court of Kansas· 1930-03-19· cited 6×
- Anderson v. DurrOhio Court of Appeals· 1919-02-03· cited 4×
- State ex rel. Goetzman v. Minnesota Tax CommissionSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1917-03-02· cited 4×
- Missouri Pacific Railroad v. Reynolds-Davis Grocery Co.Supreme Court of Arkansas· 1923-12-24· cited 2×
Cites
20 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Bell's Gap Railroad v. PennsylvaniaSupreme Court· 1890-03-10· cited 449×
- North Carolina Railroad v. ZacharySupreme Court· 1914-02-02· cited 366×
- Van Allen v. AssessorsSupreme Court· 1866-03-26· cited 256×
- Farrington v. TennesseeSupreme Court· 1878-01-14· cited 206×
- New Orleans v. StempelSupreme Court· 1899-12-04· cited 165×
- Tappan v. Merchants' National BankSupreme Court· 1874-04-13· cited 139×
- Metropolitan Life Insurance v. City of New OrleansSupreme Court· 1907-04-08· cited 113×
- Sparhawk v. YerkesSupreme Court· 1891-12-07· cited 112×
- Hyde v. WoodsSupreme Court· 1877-04-30· cited 107×
- Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. SowersSupreme Court· 1909-03-01· cited 104×
- Liverpool & London & Globe Insurance v. Board of Assessors for Parish of OrleansSupreme Court· 1911-05-15· cited 95×
- Hawley v. City of MaldenSupreme Court· 1914-01-05· cited 93×
- Gaar, Scott & Co. v. ShannonSupreme Court· 1912-02-19· cited 64×
- Page v. EdmundsSupreme Court· 1903-01-05· cited 56×
- Clement National Bank v. VermontSupreme Court· 1913-11-10· cited 51×
- American Express Co. v. MullinsSupreme Court· 1909-02-23· cited 49×
- Miedreich v. LauensteinSupreme Court· 1914-02-02· cited 43×
- Hammond v. JohnstonSupreme Court· 1891-12-14· cited 28×
- San José Land & Water Co. v. San José Ranch Co.Supreme Court· 1903-03-02· cited 23×
- Carlson v. Washington Ex Rel. CurtissSupreme Court· 1914-05-25· cited 14×
Other cases named Rogers v. Hennepin County
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.