Richardson v. Dybedahl
Citations
- 14 S.D. 126
- 84 N.W. 486
- 1900 S.D. LEXIS 17
Syllabus
<p>1. By Comp. Laws, § 1277, it is the duty of the road overseer to remove obstructions in any highway in his township; by Section 6381, every one obstructing a public officer'in'the discharge of his duty is guilty of a misdemeanor, and Section 7148 declares that a peace officer may arrest, for a public offense committed in his presence, without warrant. Held, that where in an action for malicious prosecution, it appeared that the overseer of highways had attempted to remove a fence on plaintiff’s land, on the ground that it obstructed a highway, and there was evidence showing that she resisted such removal, and she was arrested by a deputy sheriff without a warrant, and she claimed that defendants instructed the sheriff to arrest her, the issue-to be determined was not whether a highway had been legally established, so that plaintiff’s conduct was a public offense under Section 6381, justifying her arrest under- Section 7148, but whether the facts were such as to have led a person of ordinary caution to believe such to be the case.</p> <p>2. If defendants instructed the officer to arrest plaintiff, and plaintiff was afterwards discharged without hearing, their liability was the same as if they had instituted proceedings.</p> <p>3. There could be n-o recovery unless both malice and want of probable cause were shown.</p> <p>4. In an action for malicious prosecution, malice may be inferred from want of probable cause.</p> <p>5. The question whether there was a want of probable cause was for the jury.</p> <p>6. It being necessary to determine what facts were known to defendants when the arrest was made, it was proper to admjt in evidence the proceedings relating to the establishment of the highway, showing the position of the highway on the earth’s surface, and what inquiries had been made and what advice taken by defendants as to the Iocs tion and legality of the highway.</p> <p>7. Where plaintiff claimed that her arrest at the instance of defendants had been illegal,
Judges: Fuuuer, Hanky
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
5 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Manuel v. WilkaSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 2000-05-10· cited 27×
- Darrow v. SchumacherSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1993-02-03· cited 23×
- Huntley v. HarbertsSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1978-04-06· cited 10×
- Brown v. KeyesSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1929-03-02· cited 9×
- Richardson v. DybedahlSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1904-02-03· cited 3×
Cites
9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Samuel Kirk & Son v. GarrettCourt of Appeals of Maryland· 1896-12-03· cited 41×
- Cochran v. ToherSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1869-07-15· cited 33×
- Brock v. StimsonMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1871-11-15· cited 32×
- Hutchins v. ShawMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1850-09-15· cited 13×
- Jackson v. BellSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1894-04-13· cited 11×
- Richardson v. HustonSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1898-02-16· cited 9×
- Snead v. BonnoilAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1900-03-16· cited 4×
- Neys v. TaylorSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1900-02-07· cited 2×
- Murray v. FriensbergNew York Supreme Court· 1891-07-11· cited 1×
Other cases named Richardson v. Dybedahl
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.